Loeb vs Pak

Who writes the biggest BS Hulk story?

They're are no BS Hulk stories but people who read comic books and expect some realism in the story when it's a work of fiction.

Loeb.

Pak wrote Planet Hulk, which was awesome.

Rulk handed current Thor his butt. Took Mjolnir from him and used it against him.

Loeb is easily the biggest BS peddler!

Who wants to guess who Rulk is? I was betting heavily on Doc Samson for a while, but these new abilities make me think it's a cosmic being. The Beyonder maybe, is he still suppose to be in the Kyln?

Pak has like 1 shit story, Loeb has 50?

loeb has however many he's written

Originally posted by Rorschach
Loeb.

Pak wrote Planet Hulk, which was awesome.

rulk can k.o. the watcher but can only put down abomination with the help of a gun,also can beat thor up with his own hammer yet he can only kill a wendigo with the aid of a hot steel poker,f*cking bullshit.

loeb is a genius!!!!1!! durfist

i vote that whatever loeb writes be considered out of continuity
and that it be filed away to its own little universe/reality
earth loeb

Loeb. RedHulk is completely random. Pak has written a number of very good Hulk stories including PlanetHulk, the only one that is much of a problem is WWH.

Loeb has some great stuff as well, Hush in example.

Originally posted by llagrok
Loeb has some great stuff as well, Hush in example.

Okay, but how many good stories has he written since coming to work for Marvel?

Jeph Loeb must be a saboteur for DC.

Originally posted by llagrok
Loeb has some great stuff as well, Hush in example.

I don't recall Hulk appearing in Hush . . .

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
I don't recall Hulk appearing in Hush . . .

dur me

Originally posted by Symmetric Chaos
I don't recall Hulk appearing in Hush . . .

Hulk is in every comic ever writted, FACT.

I would say Loeb. Not only is the power of Red Hulk pretty much at random levels, but the dialogue sucks too. "Hulk is not a pile of hammers!" ftl.

the dialogue sucks too. "Hulk is not a pile of hammers!" ftl.

Quoting for freaking truth. What is it about Marvel hiring people who can't write a dialogue?

umm, not to be a stick in the mud but 1) surely 'that' line isn't the worst you can recall? ("oh the humanity!"?) and 2) wasn't it actually "bag of hammers"?

anyway, I was bored with the whole Guess The Hulk stuff after a couple of issues. THERE IS NO HULK BUT HULK and Pak is his messenger, as ALL our holybooks say!

I don't like Red "Hulk", but as a character, this Red is proving to be phenomenally funny... sharp, fast, powerful (upper range of Hulk feats, mostly) and vicious.

the gun thing was just being a "bad ass" (as you Americans would say), he didn't need it to finish off Abomination, I think I recall him saying so too.

I'm hoping that the proper, undisputed heavy weight champion of Hulk-dom - King Hulk - returns to bury this wannabe.

Originally posted by Knowsbleed33
Rulk handed current Thor his butt. Took Mjolnir from him and used it against him.

Originally posted by Dark-Jaxx
Huh? Didn't read that yet......

Neither did I. I saw the scans though. Takes the hammer right out of Thors hands and hits him with it.