PROFESSIONAL BODY BUILDER vs PROFESSIONAL WEIGHT LIFTER whod win in a brawl?

Started by Mindship2 pages

Originally posted by dadudemon
However, it really is light weight, relative to him, on the video I posted.
What's equally impressive, but not visible thanks to Coleman's skill, is the tremendous strength that goes into just balancing the dumbells, let alone pressing them. Anyone who's worked with barbells and dumbells knows what I'm talking about.

Originally posted by Kosta
How much someone can lift and how big someone is has little to do with how well they perform in a fight.
True.

If anything it slows them down due to their mass.
Not necessarily. Muscles will do as they're trained to do, and I personally did not find myself lacking in speed compared to my slimmer sparring partners. If anything, my friend would b*tch how it was tougher to get at my ribs because my larger arms covered up more body.

Don't get me wrong, there is a happy medium, but for the most part, once you get pasty a certain size, especially the size apparent in most bodybuilders, you are considerably slower than an opponent who is smaller and trains their muscles for speed and strength as apposed to mass. Fast twitch muscle fibers are largely more present in people that train for strength and speed as apposed to mass. There are exceptions to this, as some people are gifted with plenty of both. I'm no expert, but these are some things Ive gathered over the past few years of weight training and messing around with some MMA. Having said that I guess that the weightlifter would most probably have an advantage of speed over the bodybuilder due to his or hers increased muscle fiber to size ratio.

Either way though, I'd just fight dirty is someone twice the size that I am came at me. Survival is key. 😛

Originally posted by Mindship
What's equally impressive, but not visible thanks to Coleman's skill, is the tremendous strength that goes into just balancing the dumbells, let alone pressing them. Anyone who's worked with barbells and dumbells knows what I'm talking about.

Yup, exactly right, integrating dumbells in to your workout in exercises such as bench press and shoulder press adds an element of balance that increases the workload on the muscle being used. Barbells don't have that as much because youre not using as much of your core to balance the weight, due to it being one mass. That's why I use mostly dumbells where I can.

Originally posted by Kosta
Don't get me wrong, there is a happy medium, but for the most part, once you get pasty a certain size, especially the size apparent in most bodybuilders, you are considerably slower than an opponent who is smaller and trains their muscles for speed and strength as apposed to mass.
No argument here.

Either way though, I'd just fight dirty is someone twice the size that I am came at me. Survival is key. 😛
To survival... drunk

Sorry friend, I have no idea regarding to this matter.
If I found anywhere then I will tell you.

😕 😕

Originally posted by JacopeX
Who would want to watch a bunch of muscle heads grapple each other for hours?

Why would you want to see people kick a ball around for ninety minutes?

Originally posted by Barker
Why would you want to see people kick a ball around for ninety minutes?
Why would you want to see a bunch of jerks with over protected gear on top of each other for hours?