Mace Vs. Jaina

Classic 3:

1. Saber
2. Force
3. All out

Takes place on the plains of Naboo.

Mace: RotS
Jaina: Invincible.

Mace takes all three. The only way Jaina was able to defeat Caedus was by getting in a cheap shot before they fought every single time, so that feat doesn't really say much for her. Mace, by contrast, is a much better swordsman and Force user.

agreed.

I would have thought that learning shatterpoint, "Jedi Killing Techniques" and the whole 'Sword of the Jedi' thing might have given her enough to scrape a win at least going all out.

Jaina is incredibly strong in the force, as shown by her piloting skills, and her strength when working with Jacen, probably b/c she is the Great-Granddaughter of the force (The Force/Plageius- Anakin- Leia).
She learned tactics from Boba, and isn't chained to a mentality of fighting on even footing.

Bottom line, she might have a chance (say 4/10 wins) in an all out fight w/ Mace.