TPM obi-wan vs ROTJ luke

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
And no, what "canon" novel was it?

It was the resurrection comic http://www.swtimeline.ru/?view=969&size=M&page=002

This is tough. I'd have to say Obi wan due to the fact that he started training from a younger age.

And its part of the canonical Star Wars time line that Maul came back and fought Darth Vader? Does anything in here mention his power or skill level?

Originally posted by Darth Subjekt
And its part of the canonical Star Wars time line that Maul came back and fought Darth Vader? Does anything in here mention his power or skill level?

This Maul is canon, the cyborg one and the one Luke fights in a comic is not canon to my knowledge. And to my knowledge there nothing about his power level,the comic is only 30 or so pages long all the reads are other "star wars:tales"

Here is a brief overview but its been a while since I read it.

Basically the 2 fight and they seem pretty evenly matched but Maul injures Vader as well as being the faster of the two while Vader I believe breaks Maul's saber in two. Maul has Vader beat(he is right behind Vader right now) then says/taunts something like "who do you hate to destroy me?" vader says "myself," then stabs his saber through his body and into Maul as Maul was about to kill Vader. But Maul dies Vader is severely injured, Palpatine suddenly shows up and he unleashes force lightning on the prophets of the darkside who "resurrected" Maul and I believe he turns their bodies to ash. The end.

Fascinating.

Originally posted by Elite Hunter
This Maul is canon, the cyborg one and the one Luke fights in a comic is not canon to my knowledge. And to my knowledge there nothing about his power level,the comic is only 30 or so pages long all the reads are other "star wars:tales"

Here is a brief overview but its been a while since I read it.

Basically the 2 fight and they seem pretty evenly matched but Maul injures Vader as well as being the faster of the two while Vader I believe breaks Maul's saber in two. Maul has Vader beat(he is right behind Vader right now) then says/taunts something like "who do you hate to destroy me?" vader says "myself," then stabs his saber through his body and into Maul as Maul was about to kill Vader.

Maybe I read it wrong (Checked, pretty sure I didn't), but Maul didn't ask what he hated that much until after he got stabbed. From what I could see, Vader waited until Maul went in for the kill then grabbed the lightsaber Maul essentially just fell on top of it. Because you see he lunges forward just as Vader grabs the saber and stabs himself. So.. Maul essentially lunged onto it. 😂

That's a sick comic though.

Originally posted by Blax_Hydralisk
Maybe I read it wrong (Checked, pretty sure I didn't), but Maul didn't ask what he hated that much until after he got stabbed. From what I could see, Vader waited until Maul went in for the kill then grabbed the lightsaber Maul essentially just fell on top of it. Because you see he lunges forward just as Vader grabs the saber and stabs himself. So.. Maul essentially lunged onto it. 😂

That's a sick comic though.

IDk I haven't read it in a while. It was something along like that, but what vader did was bad@$$.

luke wins all 3 of them easily 😉

Originally posted by Lt. Valerian
Yes, so did Luke, but does that mean ROTJ Luke is superior to Darth Vader? Because as far as I can see, almost exactly the same happened in TPM and ROTJ, between Kenobi and Maul/Vader and Luke.

Still, he might've killed Maul, but it was only because Maul was overly-confident. In other words, he got lucky.