Thrawn with Revan as a Second in command

Started by MasterAshenVor4 pages

Thrawn and Revan take this...Since they have oh...say 2 super weapons and ALL of the Executer Star Destroyers and...oh say HALF of the Empire's Star Destroyer Navy and ALL of the Tie Fighters therein and since Thrawn was brilliant as hell and Revan was a very very good tactician id say it would be a good match aginst both Vong and CIS forces but after say five days of battle or maby a Week of that battle Revan and Thrawn would come out victorious but with almost ALL of their navy destroyed Includeing all of his Executor Class Star Destroyers except one which is badly damaged and a little over Half of his Star Destroyers destroyed o.o and virtually almost ALL of the Tie Fighters , Bombers , Interceptors , GUN's , Missle Boats , Tie Defenders , Carrack Cruisers and Victory Class Star Destroyers....o.o HEAVY HEAVY Loses and i think maby one of the Eclipse Super Star Destroyers....But the CIS and VONG would be completely wiped out...and Revan would be dead too and Thrawn being wounded due to Minor Terminal Explosions on the Bridge....Gilad Pellaeron would be alive but wounded too...maby even lose a Hand .... But id say Empire Wins...

THEN ALL OF A SUDDEN EIGHT MON CAL CRUISERS HYPER IN WITH FULL LOADS OF X-WINGS Y-WINGS B-WINGS A-WINGS AND TEN NEBULON-B CRUISERS THREE MARAUDER CLASS STARSHIPS AND TEN CORELLIAN CORVETTES COME IN AND WIPE THE REST OF THEM OUT WITH ONLY 1 CORELLIAN CORVETTE INTACT AND ONLY 7 NEBULON-B FRIGATE'S INTACT AND 7 MON CAL CRUISERS INTACT AND ALL MARAUDER CLASS DESTROYED!!! plus seven squadrons of X-WINGS still active and only 1 B-wing squad active and 3 Y-wing squads active and Eight A-WING squadrons still active

what the hey? 🤨 🤨

Originally posted by MasterAshenVor
Thrawn and Revan take this...Since they have oh...say 2 super weapons and ALL of the Executer Star Destroyers and...oh say HALF of the Empire's Star Destroyer Navy and ALL of the Tie Fighters therein and since Thrawn was brilliant as hell and Revan was a very very good tactician id say it would be a good match aginst both Vong and CIS forces but after say five days of battle or maby a Week of that battle Revan and Thrawn would come out victorious but with almost ALL of their navy destroyed Includeing all of his Executor Class Star Destroyers except one which is badly damaged and a little over Half of his Star Destroyers destroyed o.o and virtually almost ALL of the Tie Fighters , Bombers , Interceptors , GUN's , Missle Boats , Tie Defenders , Carrack Cruisers and Victory Class Star Destroyers....o.o HEAVY HEAVY Loses and i think maby one of the Eclipse Super Star Destroyers....But the CIS and VONG would be completely wiped out...and Revan would be dead too and Thrawn being wounded due to Minor Terminal Explosions on the Bridge....Gilad Pellaeron would be alive but wounded too...maby even lose a Hand .... But id say Empire Wins...

THEN ALL OF A SUDDEN EIGHT MON CAL CRUISERS HYPER IN WITH FULL LOADS OF X-WINGS Y-WINGS B-WINGS A-WINGS AND TEN NEBULON-B CRUISERS THREE MARAUDER CLASS STARSHIPS AND TEN CORELLIAN CORVETTES COME IN AND WIPE THE REST OF THEM OUT WITH ONLY 1 CORELLIAN CORVETTE INTACT AND ONLY 7 NEBULON-B FRIGATE'S INTACT AND 7 MON CAL CRUISERS INTACT AND ALL MARAUDER CLASS DESTROYED!!! plus seven squadrons of X-WINGS still active and only 1 B-wing squad active and 3 Y-wing squads active and Eight A-WING squadrons still active

Wow, you really thought this one through.
Oops.

Originally posted by MasterAshenVor
THEN ALL OF A SUDDEN EIGHT MON CAL CRUISERS HYPER IN WITH FULL LOADS OF X-WINGS Y-WINGS B-WINGS A-WINGS AND TEN NEBULON-B CRUISERS THREE MARAUDER CLASS STARSHIPS AND TEN CORELLIAN CORVETTES COME IN AND WIPE THE REST OF THEM OUT WITH ONLY 1 CORELLIAN CORVETTE INTACT AND ONLY 7 NEBULON-B FRIGATE'S INTACT AND 7 MON CAL CRUISERS INTACT AND ALL MARAUDER CLASS DESTROYED!!! plus seven squadrons of X-WINGS still active and only 1 B-wing squad active and 3 Y-wing squads active and Eight A-WING squadrons still active
I read the first word of this and thought: "Then Gandalf the Grey, and Gandalf the White..."

LMFAO!!!!

Oh come on. This is a joke, right?

Let me point this out for you: The Republic did keep the CIS at bay with about 1,3 Million Clone Troopers and corresponding capital ships (that would be about 200-400 Venator Class ships).

Now have a look at the start posting of this thread:

2 Eclipse-class ships: 100 times the firepower of a regular ISD + superlaser capable of annihilating enemy capital ships with a single shot.

All Executor-class ships: At least 8 of them appear in the SW mythos. Yet each of that has 100 times the firepower of an regular ISD. On top of that almost impenetrable shielding. You did all notice how it took the Rebel fleet about 30 minutes in RotJ to get past the Executors shields, when they were focusing their entire fire on that single ship (which wasn't even firing back)? Technically one of that alone is enough to take out an entire enemy fleet. In fact it has been said that a Mandator-class Star Dreadnaught (something compareable to the Executor class) could have taken out 1,000 CIS capital ships on it's own.

200,000 ISDs: You notice that this is 500-1000 times the firepower of the entire Navy of the Galactic Republic in times of the Clone Wars, right? And yes: It also means a thousand times more ground troops, when single Clone Troopers during the Clone Wars had confirmed 2,000 droid kills in their field record. On top of that millions of attack vessels (AT-ATs, AT-STs) and starfighters.

To make the long story short: In space combat, the Vong and the CIS are royally screwed. For ground combat: Each ISD can start a Base Delta Zero operation, which makes ground combat unnecessary. And even if that option should be ignored the droids would be curpstombed in ground combat action. By skill, technology and firepower alone.

And this is still ignoring the military genious of Thrawn and Revan which have both managed to win battles where they were heavily outnumbered by their enemies. This time they already have all advantages on their own side. This is overkill.

Originally posted by Borbarad
Oh come on. This is a joke, right?

Let me point this out for you: The Republic did keep the CIS at bay with about 1,3 Million Clone Troopers and corresponding capital ships (that would be about 200-400 Venator Class ships).

Now have a look at the start posting of this thread:

2 Eclipse-class ships: 100 times the firepower of a regular ISD + superlaser capable of annihilating enemy capital ships with a single shot.

All Executor-class ships: At least 8 of them appear in the SW mythos. Yet each of that has 100 times the firepower of an regular ISD. On top of that almost impenetrable shielding. You did all notice how it took the Rebel fleet about 30 minutes in RotJ to get past the Executors shields, when they were focusing their entire fire on that single ship (which wasn't even firing back)? Technically one of that alone is enough to take out an entire enemy fleet. In fact it has been said that a Mandator-class Star Dreadnaught (something compareable to the Executor class) could have taken out 1,000 CIS capital ships on it's own.

200,000 ISDs: You notice that this is 500-1000 times the firepower of the entire Navy of the Galactic Republic in times of the Clone Wars, right? And yes: It also means a thousand times more ground troops, when single Clone Troopers during the Clone Wars had confirmed 2,000 droid kills in their field record. On top of that millions of attack vessels (AT-ATs, AT-STs) and starfighters.

To make the long story short: In space combat, the Vong and the CIS are royally screwed. For ground combat: Each ISD can start a Base Delta Zero operation, which makes ground combat unnecessary. And even if that option should be ignored the droids would be curpstombed in ground combat action. By skill, technology and firepower alone.

And this is still ignoring the military genious of Thrawn and Revan which have both managed to win battles where they were heavily outnumbered by their enemies. This time they already have all advantages on their own side. This is overkill.


No, no no it is not possible for the Republic to have done that, there had to be at least a billion clones, and even with a billion clones they were outnumbered a billion to one. And ISDs aren't the only ones who can do this, Grievous turned Humbmarine into Molten slag with his armada, oh and he released a brain virus that kills all humans in a given sector. And in AOTC it is stated that their are 200,000 units, I'd enterpret this as battallions putting with a million more the Galactic Republic's total strenght being 700,000,000+ then you have the massive personal fleets of individual systems which adds to that number alot. I still say that the Republic had more than a billion clones. Alot more

Originally posted by Mizukage Yoda
No, no no it is not possible for the Republic to have done that, there had to be at least a billion clones, and even with a billion clones they were outnumbered a billion to one. And ISDs aren't the only ones who can do this, Grievous turned Humbmarine into Molten slag with his armada, oh and he released a brain virus that kills all humans in a given sector. And in AOTC it is stated that their are 200,000 units, I'd enterpret this as battallions putting with a million more the Galactic Republic's total strenght being 700,000,000+ then you have the massive personal fleets of individual systems which adds to that number alot. I still say that the Republic had more than a billion clones. Alot more
While that would make perfect sense, your opinion<canon. I forget who, but some bastard of an author put it down as 1.2 million, which makes absolutely no sense. Still, canon is as canon does.

Its simply not possible. Period another sourse says ten million another says three million. Based on depictions clones cannot go a quadrillion to one its not possible. And at the Battle of Munnilist alone there were 3.2 million clones hear is the discussion on the Wookiepedia.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Grand_Army_of_the_Republic#Numbers
Hear is a quote by Ryan Koffman
"FYI, re: 3 million. LFL was very clear to us that no fixed number of total clones would or could be assigned. Therefore, the number 3 million (plus) does not represent the entire fighting force."
―Ryan Kaufman

^ Tell that to Karen Traviss who is the author of the new of the new clone wars source book I believe.

Originally posted by Mizukage Yoda
Its simply not possible. Period another sourse says ten million another says three million. Based on depictions clones cannot go a quadrillion to one its not possible. And at the Battle of Munnilist alone there were 3.2 million clones hear is the discussion on the Wookiepedia.

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Grand_Army_of_the_Republic#Numbers
Hear is a quote by Ryan Koffman
"FYI, re: 3 million. LFL was very clear to us that no fixed number of total clones would or could be assigned. Therefore, the number 3 million (plus) does not represent the entire fighting force."
―Ryan Kaufman

I know, I've read that entire article before. But, it's stuck at 1.2 million. And if it was Karen Traviss: oh, that b*tch just won't stop ruining things.

I will write to Lucasarts then...cause that is retarded simply put, its simply not possible. The US army is stretched thin across the world with the same amount of troops let alone if they were spread across an entire galaxy...simply bullshit. Can I have some of what your smoking George!?

Originally posted by Mizukage Yoda
I will write to Lucasarts then...cause that is retarded simply put, its simply not possible. The US army is stretched thin across the world with the same amount of troops let alone if they were spread across an entire galaxy...simply bullshit. Can I have some of what your smoking George!?

The US Army numbers barely over one million, including the Reserve and the National Guard.

Let's not forget that the clone troopers weren't the only ones fighting in the war. Locally conscripted troops, independant militaries as well as the Jedi Order count for something.

quintillions of battledroids
2000000000000000000+ battledroids. The GAR's core is the clone army. With a billion man army they are still outnumbered a billion to one. I'd say they'd need at least a trillion men to stand a reasonable chance against the droids. If the GAR was 1.3 million clones then the CIS has more CAPITAL SHIPS than the Republic has clones, lets use some logic here.

Yes. Let's use some logic here, and stick to the topic of this thread, hmm? You know, the one where Thrawn and Revan with their militaries walk over the Vong and CIS armies before trashing Krayt's Empire with outdated relics of the past.

ROFL! you think the Thrawn and Revan will "walk over" the Vong and the CIS you overestimate there Prowest. What part of millions of warships, and GG don't you get. Oh and Dooku can practically rally many systems to his side, something that neither Thrawn or Revan(well maybe Revan, but not as well as Dooku) can do. The Majority of the Galaxy will most likely side with the Confederacy. Honestly, even if they got past the CIS and the Vong's armada, they'd still get pwnt by Krayt, Why? because they would take astounding casualties in this.

Please, stop being ridiculous.

Nai and the others covered it quite nicely, but you still don't seem to understand. The Galactic Empire, in terms of military might, is peerless; there is no governmental entity or society that can compete with them on any level. The Complete Visual Guide confirms that the Empire's military build up was "unprecedented in galactic history" in both scale and equipment. The Yuuzhan Vong deliberately remained on the fringes of the galactic disk because they feared incurring the Emperor's wrath; Nom Anor, one of their finest Executors, feared the Empire so much that even after Palpatine's final death on Onderon, when the Empire was heavily fragmented and dissolved, he still considered the remnants to be a greater threat than the New Republic and orchestrated the death of the final psuedo-Emperor.

The Confederacy of Independent Systems might compete in sheer numbers (and this is speaking only in regards to ground forces), but their naval output cannot compare. The Yuuzhan Vong, likewise, may be a threat in ground engagements, but not naval.

Naval > ground, and as Nai has alluded to, the 'delta base zero' is one of the most used Imperial techniques. If they find a situation untenable on ground, Thrawn will simply blow the planet the **** away from orbit.

Originally posted by Mizukage Yoda
The Majority of the Galaxy will most likely side with the Confederacy.

Lol even in clone wars the majority of the galaxy was against them.

Oh this also encompasses half of the Imperial Military...shit, they also fielded millions of Capitals. The Empire would win then they have the Vong and the CIS outnumbered, outgunned, and well Thrawn is the best strategist in the history of the Galaxy, besides me in EAW. But at the original figures Thrawn and Revan would lose, simply put.
Oh and of coarse the Galaxy would side with PALPATINE! the most charismic leader in the History of the Galaxy, this man made a Senate that stood for a thousand years declare itself into an Empire

Oh shit I didn't realize Thrawn and Revan get Mandalorians on their side and with Traviss's writing of them there is no doubt in mind that the CIS and Vong are screwed.

Oh and of coarse the Galaxy would side with PALPATINE! the most charismic leader in the History of the Galaxy, this man made a Senate that stood for a thousand years declare itself into an Empire

Then why did you say this originally?

The Majority of the Galaxy will most likely side with the Confederacy.