Superman vs Thanos

Originally posted by psycho gundam
oh the irony 🙄

Seriously, If you were to say someone shoots someone else, it would be on me to prove it wouldn't work.

galactus' energy beam was a sustained assault on the shield of thanos, and it still didn't fully penetrate it.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
galactus' energy beam was a sustained assault on the shield of thanos, and it still didn't fully penetrate it.

Thats energy based attacks, not physical ones.

To be fair, that means you're claiming that the shield can't stand up to physical attacks as well as it can energy based attacks, which means the burden is on you.

Originally posted by Silent Master
To be fair, that means you're claiming that the shield can't stand up to physical attacks as well as it can energy based attacks, which means the burden is on you.

No they are the one trying to prove that the two are the same. The onus is on them.

Originally posted by Avlon
Let's not forget that dumb drax took a hell of a blast from Odin as well and wasn't really hurt.

Thanos battle against Odin was a curbstomp in Odins favor. The most impressive thing about it was Thanos staying alive long enough for Odin to change his mind about killing him.

Supes and Thanos have compable feats and that's with Thanos usually having some kind of prep against opponents and Supes having to deal with stuff on the fly.

This thread has been made quite a few times though. My vote usually goes that it can go either way.

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix
No they are the one trying to prove that the two are the same. The onus is on them.

No, you're trying to shift the burden to them by claiming there is a difference in a shield's durability based on whether it gets hit with energy or physical attacks. which again, puts the burden on you.

Originally posted by Silent Master
No, you're trying to shift the burden to them by claiming there is a difference in a shield's durability based on whether it gets hit with energy or physical attacks. which again, puts the burden on you.

They are two different types of attack, so it's perfectly valid for me to ask that they prove that they hit with the same force and effect.

they definitely aren't the same, the shield has been tested twice;

-once by champion wielding the power gem and enraged that thanos was evading his blows. thanos in a mocking fashion then let champion tee off on his shield. under normal conditions the shield would have endured, but champ was in possession of the power gem and with subconscious tapping of it's power he increased his attack power with each consecutive blow. (champion then shattered the planet)

*note superman lacks the power gem*

- and the second was the more recent galactus incident.

*note. galactus is a trans skyfather being*

at the end of the day it comes down to power. superman lacks the cosmic or solar for that matter to just take down the shield to begin with. after hitting it over and over again and blasting it with hv, he will soon realize that thanos can't be touched. and if he tires it will only get worse once thanos hits him with his power cosmic.

Originally posted by Juntai

Thanos battle against Odin was a curbstomp in Odins favor.

The most impressive thing about it
was Thanos staying alive long enough for Odin to change his mind about killing him.

I studied that battle in-depth,
imo, it was more of a stalemate,
with Odin slightly winning perhaps by a point,
which was towards the end when they struggled over the Trident.

(although admit-tingly, from a judges scorecard point of view, Odin won in a split decision imo)

Also, Odin never changed his mind about doing anything to Thanos,
the fight was going to continue, Thanos was pulsing with energy and ready for more,
then Sif and BRB interrupted the fight, and then both Odin and Thanos stopped.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
they definitely aren't the same

-once by champion wielding the power gem and enraged that thanos was evading his blows. . under normal conditions the shield would have endured,[/QUOTE]
The shield was collapsing and you have to prove the second part.

Saying it was a stalemate implies that they were roughly equal which is rather funny for anyone that is both unbiased and has seen the fight.

Originally posted by Mr Master
I have to disagree here friends, Odin most definitely did not curbstomp Thanos.

I studied that battle in-depth,
imo, it was more of a stalemate,
with Odin slightly winning perhaps by a point,
which was towards the end when they struggle over the Trident.

Also, Odin never changed his mind about doing anything to Thanos,
the fight was going to continue, Thanos was pulsing with energy and ready for more,
then Sif and BRB interrupted the fight, and then both Odin and Thanos stopped.

I think Thanos was pretty much whipped towards the end though. If that fight would have continued, Thanos would have lost fairly quickly after that point in my opinion. Odin was getting pissed and each attack seemed more powerful than the last. Thanos was heading downhill from the beginning.

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix
Exactly thank you for admitting that.

-once by champion wielding the power gem and enraged that thanos was evading his blows. . under normal conditions the shield would have endured,

So you think that Superman flying and ramming into Thanos would be more powerful than the Champions punching power with the Power Gem?

Originally posted by Silent Master

Saying it was a stalemate implies that they were roughly equal
which is rather funny for anyone that is both unbiased and has seen the fight.

It was rather equal, until the very end,
when Thanos finally went down for a moment once,
but Thanos got back up, did not yield, and was ready for more.

Those are the facts.

Originally posted by Aster Phoenix
Exactly, He would simply fly at Thanos full speed.

i see this is still on going with aster phoenix asking everbody to prove something,despite him not proving a damn thing other than "saying"imo supes rams thanos to death.

i say to you prove it can kill thanos with evidance

Originally posted by tkitna
The shield was collapsing and you have to prove the second part.

Originally posted by Priest
Then it is a request that will be dismissed.
You have u a issue number, prove me wrong 🙂
Google the issue number, I'm sure u can find issue summaries.

Don't bother to respond to this...I'm not here to do your biddings.

Originally posted by Avlon
Let's not forget that dumb drax took a hell of a blast from Odin as well and wasn't really hurt.

Thanos battle against Odin was a curbstomp in Odins favor. The most impressive thing about it was Thanos staying alive long enough for Odin to change his mind about killing him.

Supes and Thanos have compable feats and that's with Thanos usually having some kind of prep against opponents and Supes having to deal with stuff on the fly.

This thread has been made quite a few times though. My vote usually goes that it can go either way.

When did Odin change his mind about killing Thanos?

This fight doesnt go either way. It goes Thanos way every single time.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
oh the irony 🙄

Originally posted by Nihilist
i see this is still on going

Oh yes, you could literally rename this thread "The Neverending Story".