Should Windu have assmebled a better team?

As good as the team was that Windu had to confront the Emperor, should have have not waited for Yoda to make his move? The two of them would have certainly overwhelmed Palpatine...Discuss

It would have been impossible. Aside from Anakin, he picked the best swordsmen who were readily available.

Edit: And, no, he couldn't wait for Sidious to make his move. Too dangerous.

Originally posted by norrinradd43
As good as the team was that Windu had to confront the Emperor, should have have not waited for Yoda to make his move? The two of them would have certainly overwhelmed Palpatine...Discuss

lol, what do you think? haermm

That is true, not to mention he had no Idea Palpatine was as good as he was...the team would have appeared to be more than adiquate. Had he chose Anikin, there is a good chance he would have stuck with the Jedi, so that is the one thing he could have done to change the outcome aside from secretly calling Yoda away from his battle.

Originally posted by norrinradd43
That is true, not to mention he had no Idea Palpatine was as good as he was.

Palpatine was a sith lord that corrupted the senate. I know Mace was black but he seemed like he could do the math.

Originally posted by norrinradd43
Had he chose Anikin, there is a good chance he would have stuck with the Jedi, so that is the one thing he could have done to change the outcome aside from secretly calling Yoda away from his battle.

The whole point is that he had to act quickly. Mace never trusted Anakin when it came to Palpatine. Mace made the biggest mistake by not waiting until Yoda was present. He was the actual downfall of the republic, imo. The black man should of just waited for his little green master and they could be drinking margarita's on the beach screwin Padme.

Now Lucas is. What a waste ..

Wtf were they thinking?!?

HERE IS WHAT HE SHOULD HAVE DONE.

1. Tie up anakin and shove him in the closet.
2. TAKE EVERY FRICKING JEDI IN THE ORDER TO CONFRONT THE CHANCELLOR. Omg its a sith that is so powerful two of his apprentices killed one of our most promising masters, owned our two greatest swordsman, started two wars, owned the chosen one, and held up against Yoda.

Sooo he brings three jedis. Sure they may be some of the greatest, but if sideous's apprentices racked up the above score, he should have had the imagination to decide that he should have brought overkill.

Originally posted by Ahsoka Tano
Palpatine was a sith lord that corrupted the senate. I know Mace was black but he seemed like he could do the math.

Hahaha.

I think if Mace brought more Jedi there would be too many and they would be killed one at a time like how Palpatine killed the first two (no way in !@#$ I will try to spell their names) Then he fought Kit and Mace for a little bit together before killing Kit. The Jedi were never able to pull an attack where all four were giving it to Palpatine.

Originally posted by sweersa
I think if Mace brought more Jedi there would be too many and they would be killed one at a time like how Palpatine killed the first two (no way in !@#$ I will try to spell their names)

Agen Kolar and Saesee Tiin.

😈

Originally posted by Master Crimzon
Agen Kolar and Saesee Tiin.

😈

Thank you. My spell checker (yes I use one lol) would slaughter those names.

Originally posted by sweersa
Thank you. My spell checker (yes I use one lol) would slaughter those names.

I use one too, but it can go to hell for all I care.

Originally posted by Master Crimzon
I use one too, but it can go to hell for all I care.

lol

Originally posted by sweersa
lol

'lol'?

You know, spellcheck eats 'lol', too.

Originally posted by norrinradd43
As good as the team was that Windu had to confront the Emperor, should have have not waited for Yoda to make his move? The two of them would have certainly overwhelmed Palpatine...Discuss

hWell if He brought Cin Drallig and Shaak Ti along they might have stood more of a chance. Or if Anakin weren't an emo teenager and flip out in spasms maybe him as well.

He should just not have tried to kill Palpatine. That would have been a good one.

For that matter, Yoda should have just owned Dooku and let Anakin and Obi Wan die....poor old sentimental fool.

Yea..i agree BRING ANAKIN it would have showed him that the council believed in him and they actually WANTED him there....and yes Cin Drallig , Shaak Tii , Kit Fisto , Mace Windu should have been the team.

Cin and Shaak would have been better choices than Saesae Tiin for sure...Tiin was mostly know for his piloting ability, not his swordplay if im not mistaken whereas Cin was proficient on all forms except Vapaad.

Originally posted by norrinradd43
Cin was proficient on all forms except Vapaad.

Am I in the EU section again?

Hahaha.

Interesting topic. I would say that Mace, Yoda, and Obiwan together, would have kicked his ass

and no one notices that the threadstarter wrote "as good as the team was"? Shouldn't it be "as sucky as the team was"? You bring a few Jedi along and they get stabbed within 3 seconds... heck, I'm pretty sure I can survive THAT long against a sith.

I hate the scene: it's rounding up to be a huge fight, giving you eyecandy of a 4 vs 1 (or whatever) battle... than it turns within 10 seconds in a 1-on-1. Those Jedi were litteraly just backgroundfillers.