I think it depends though.. a game like perfect dark was 'new' for its time.. a FPS (not RPG/FPS, just flat out FPS) to have a pretty good story, and awesome content to unlock to boot.. great stuff..
I've been looking at vids of this game.. and the multiplayer doesnt even look that great / special... if the single player is as lame as everyone says, but the multiplayer made up for it 10-fold.. I could see being forgiving.. but it looks very copy/paste