Shadow Guard and 5 Red Guards vs Grevious and 5 Magna Guards

Who takes it?

Entirely possible Grievous does it alone

You think so? A shadow guard alone gave Starkiller a hard time.

Game mechanics = Not canon.

Originally posted by Null ARC Avis
You think so? A shadow guard alone gave Starkiller a hard time.

damn. i liked the guards too! and it wasnt in the game, but in the comic.

The General's MagnaGuards have already shown themselves to be capable of decimating Red Guards (LoE), and Grievous is likely a more formidable combatant than all but the top twenty or so Jedi in the Order. His team owns.

I think the list of people to fight Grievous is even smaller than that. Shaak Ti was considered one of the most powerful and skilled Jedi in the Order and possibly in history and look what Grievous did to her on Coruscant

General Grievous, as written by Matthew Stover, is the third greatest badass in canon.

Well, that's if we take the CWC into account. The RotS novel alludes to the events of LoE several times; Mace's duel with Grievous and the capture of the Chancellor, to name two.

Are they both equally valid but different interpretations of the same events? Can we draw from both, despite the truckload of contradictions?

Anything that shows General Grievous in a prominent, positive light can and will be taken into consideration, as per the orders of my Master, the Great Publius.

The Red Guards in TFU, though Lightsaber wielding will get bent over by Magna Guards, and the Shadow Guard will be destroyed by Grievous.

Originally posted by Gideon
Anything that shows General Grievous in a prominent, positive light can and will be taken into consideration, as per the orders of my Master, the Great Publius.

They're classified.

Then they don't exist. You're lying, sir.

I'm not. But my Master, the Great Publius, forbids paper trails.

Rules of the Internet
Pics, or it didn't happen.

That would be a paper trail. You will not fool me, sir.

But I already have. *laughs*

By the way, have any of you people heard Orchard of Mines by Globus?

Originally posted by Faunus
Well, that's if we take the CWC into account. The RotS novel alludes to the events of LoE several times; Mace's duel with Grievous and the capture of the Chancellor, to name two.

Are they both equally valid but different interpretations of the same events? Can we draw from both, despite the truckload of contradictions?

As far as I know, it's a bit of a blend...Mace's duel happened, Grievous did kill a lot of Jedi on Coruscant and he did beat Shaak Ti