Luminara and Obi-wan vs. Mace

My first thread in years!

Anyway, so this is all of them at their prime (probably ROTS). No Force only or sabers only, just an all out fight.

Mace will get angry. Very angry.

I highly doubt that he can overcome the Order's two premier Soresu masters. Depending on the setting, he might be able to make use of his presumably superior Force-power, but against Obi-Wan gaining an advantage based on terrain is going to be difficult.

If Palpatine could take out 3 established Master Jedi in ROTS and Mace is supposed to be superior to Palpatine in swordsmanship, would it be too farfetched to assume he could take these two? Still I think the team can et some wins.

Mace isn't as fast Palpatine under his own power, and these two are Soresu masters. Their defense should be all but impenetrable alone, and together they'd be obnoxious as hell.

Yea 1on1 I think Mace could penetrate their defence after a while(Shatterpoint). But together this might be too much.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Yea 1on1 I think Mace could penetrate their defence after a while(Shatterpoint). But together this might be too much.

Seeing a shatterpoint doesn't mean that he is automatically capable of using it to his advantage. RotS Kenobi was capable of deflecting 23 strikes per second from Grievous.

Kenobi is a beast. Luminara was a high level Jedi master, and I just don't see Mace defeating the team.

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
Seeing a shatterpoint doesn't mean that he is automatically capable of using it to his advantage. RotS Kenobi was capable of deflecting 23 strikes per second from Grievous.

Tisk tisk. No exaggerations. 😉

Obi-Wan handled Grievous' 18 strikes per second, and his Soresu skills were overloaded once Grievous cranked it up to 20 strikes per second. Nothing about 23.

I've got the book right here, and I'm sorry to say you're right. it was 20/sec, not 23. My mistake. It doesn't invalidate my point though. Kenobi is fast.

And we must admit that was a severely watered down General. Nothing compared to his former Clone Wars self. Don't think Kenobi could handle him.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
And we must admit that was a severely watered down General. Nothing compared to his former Clone Wars self. Don't think Kenobi could handle him.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
And we must admit that was a severely watered down General.

TEH ROTS GRIEVUS WASNT AS GOOD AS TEH COMIX!1

Originally posted by Darth Martin

Nothing compared to his former Clone Wars self.

Originally posted by Darth Martin

Don't think Kenobi could handle him.

My translation:

The Clone wars Grievous was vastly superior to the incarnation that we see in Revenge of the Sith, which was injured by Mace Windu during LOE. "I" don't believe that Obi-Wan could take CW Grievous.

(Note: I'm only the messenger. I'm not arguing my own opinions, so don't flame me. Plz.)

lulz wat a moron u r red i cnt beliv ud sai dat

What a t-wat. 😆

althugs thsia si blaspahemy, i maust agrii wit enyaluz. grievus is alwyz a 💃 💃 😍 🧑‍⚕️ 🤘

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
TEH ROTS GRIEVUS WASNT AS GOOD AS TEH COMIX!1

HE AINT AS GOOD AS HE USE TO BE11111111

OBI1 IS <<<<<<<<<<<< THAN CLONE GREIVUS!!!!11111

My translation:

The Clone wars Grievous was vastly superior to the incarnation that we see in Revenge of the Sith, which was injured by Mace Windu during LOE. "I" don't believe that Obi-Wan could take CW Grievous.

(Note: I'm only the messenger. I'm not arguing my own opinions, so don't flame me. Plz.)

Originally posted by Master Crimzon
althugs thsia si blaspahemy, i maust agrii wit enyaluz. grievus is alwyz a 💃 💃 😍 🧑‍⚕️ 🤘

Blasphemy? The above is the best and most well founded comment you've made in months.

Originally posted by Enyalus
Blasphemy? The above is the best and most well founded comment you've made in months.

You mean since I joined the forum? Why, thanks. It only speaks for how deeply incredible my previous comment was.