Originally posted by chilled monkey
Sorry, I should have been more clear. The point I was trying to make was a comparison between Kenobi and Galen's knowledge of Anakin's fighting skills.Kenobi trained Anakin and they fought as a team throughout most of the Clone Wars. So Kenobi would know Anakin's moves inside out.
Galen was trained by Vader/Anakin for most of his life. Plus they did not fight together for years as a team. My point was simply that Galen would not have the same deep knowledge and understanding of Vader's fighting style that Kenobi had.
This is all true. In retrospect your original point was correct. ABC doesn't apply here. The only problem I can see is that one of your supporting facts (the intentional gaps in Starkiller's training) didn't really apply (because he had a chance to fill those gaps). Your argument was right, but that one piece of evidence was not. Everything else seems to make sense though.
Essentially, I agree with you.