Hank Henshaw w/Rings vs Silver Surfer

Started by iceman2456710 pages

Henshaw stomps

Surfer more times than not.

Originally posted by iceman24567
Henshaw stomps
Based on what ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Once combat begins anything is fair game. You don't have to have everything come straight at the person. You have no semblance of real combat situations. I guess war is just a series of sucker shots. Awful.

Thor was weakened at the time yet still wasn't defeated. Bill has stood up against Thor just the same. Bill failed against the Surfer while Thor did not. Thor is greater than Bill all things considered.

You're lying. Do I really have to post proof of you flat out lying ?

Superman has considerable durability but when we look at the norm the Surfer is practically never cut. You just want to cite a high feat while distancing yourself from all the times he's been cut right open. Dd's bones, punches, WW's tiara, Zod broke his jaw, etc.

Surfer is more durable than Superman. I already listed enough examples you just want to say he survived this axe. Whoppty doo. That's one high feat which doesn't erase the other times he's been clashed wide open. Surfer is more durable.

Hank beat Superman that doesn't mean he beats the Surfer who is more durable, powerful, and versatile. Board to the back of Hank's head.


It was a sucker shot to the back of head to an exhausted bill. Thor is certainly more durable than bill. Its not surfer/bill/thor comparison.
Superman is more durable than surfer all around. He was weakened in DOS due to depleted solar reserves, magical tiara and a sucker shot from an equal. Surfer was gushing blood from valkyrie's knife when he has no specific weakness to magic and a clay duplicate broke his glaze completely while oneshotting him.
Feel free to post scans where thor beat surfer in B&T.
Persuader's axe cut a hole in time and space in the same issue.
Hank two shots him. Auto-shields.

Henshaw by a small margin.

Originally posted by abhilegend
It was a sucker shot to the back of head to an exhausted bill. Thor is certainly more durable than bill. Its not surfer/bill/thor comparison.
Superman is more durable than surfer all around. He was weakened in DOS due to depleted solar reserves, magical tiara and a sucker shot from an equal. Surfer was gushing blood from valkyrie's knife when he has no specific weakness to magic and a clay duplicate broke his glaze completely while oneshotting him.
Feel free to post scans where thor beat surfer in B&T.
Persuader's axe cut a hole in time and space in the same issue.
Hank two shots him. Auto-shields.
Thor fought through it. Bill didn't. Surfer destroyed him. Surfer was holding back and trying to reason with him. Bill started the fight with a sucker shot. You're a huge hypocrite.

Superman wasn't weakened in hp. You and your excuses. Surfer wouldn't be sliced right open by the magical tiara. Surfer isn't immune to all piercing attacks but the amount of times Superman has been cut compared to the Surfer isn't even close.

Superman has been sliced right open by Doomsday and there's no magic involved there.

So what ? Thor can rip holes through space and time with his hammer. No Hank doesn't. Just because he destroyed Superman doesn't have anything to do with the Surfer.

Ok will do.

One shot my ass.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Based on what ?
my opinion

Originally posted by quanchi112
Thor fought through it. Bill didn't. Surfer destroyed him. Surfer was holding back and trying to reason with him. Bill started the fight with a sucker shot. You're a huge hypocrite.

Superman wasn't weakened in hp. You and your excuses. Surfer wouldn't be sliced right open by the magical tiara. Surfer isn't immune to all piercing attacks but the amount of times Superman has been cut compared to the Surfer isn't even close.

Superman has been sliced right open by Doomsday and there's no magic involved there.

So what ? Thor can rip holes through space and time with his hammer. No Hank doesn't. Just because he destroyed Superman doesn't have anything to do with the Surfer.

Ok will do.


Thor is more durable than bill. Bill was heavily wounded when he attacked surfer with that suckershot, while surfer attacked an exhausted bill with a sucker shot.

That doomsday was adapting on fly and produced a posion to weaken him.

Yeah, he would be. A random atlantean sorcerer cleaved surfer open with a knife.

Surfer is less durable than superman.

Doomsday was adapting on the fly and destroyed an energy being with ease. I'm sure he adapted to superman's invulnerability when he produced that poison to weaken him.

Superman can do that too, he can do better than that.

Yeah, hank two shots surfer.

Ok.

Originally posted by quanchi112

One shot my ass.


Two different fights in the same issue quan. Pathetic. Post the second fight when surfer sends bill away.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Thor is more durable than bill. Bill was heavily wounded when he attacked surfer with that suckershot, while surfer attacked an exhausted bill with a sucker shot.

That doomsday was adapting on fly and produced a posion to weaken him.

Yeah, he would be. A random atlantean sorcerer cleaved surfer open with a knife.

Surfer is less durable than superman.

Doomsday was adapting on the fly and destroyed an energy being with ease. I'm sure he adapted to superman's invulnerability when he produced that poison to weaken him.

Superman can do that too, he can do better than that.

Yeah, hank two shots surfer.

Ok.

Prove Thor is more durable than Bill. Thor was weakened at the time. Just because someone can't counter that doesn't mean they are more durable. The board to the back didn't beat him his fists did.

That Doomsday ripped him wide open. I don't care he was powerful enough to cut through his skin.

A bug cut into Superman before. LOL. I can play the game too. Believe me.

Again, we debate how these guys are normally portrayed and the Surfer is more durable.

No, Superman can't. Thor's more powerful than Superman. It isn't even up for debate.

You claimed one shot.

Originally posted by abhilegend
A suckershot to an already exhausted bill. Bill owned surfer while heavily wounded. Hank wouldn't need even two punches probably. He might oneshot him like thor.
You lied. Now I exposed you because unlike you I know what I am talking about. You're wrong a lot of the time. Submit to me like you did to galan.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Two different fights in the same issue quan. Pathetic. Post the second fight when surfer sends bill away.
That was their initial conflict. You have the audacity to claim Bill's weakened but forget all the damage Thor did to Surfer prior to. You are so full of double standards and step all over yourself. He was never oneshotted. You're a liar.

Originally posted by quanchi112
That was their initial conflict. You have the audacity to claim Bill's weakened but forget all the damage Thor did to Surfer prior to. You are so full of double standards and step all over yourself. He was never oneshotted. You're a liar.

Thor was beaten down before that by bill. Here is the oneshot
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Fights/ThorvsSilverSurfer07.jpg
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Fights/ThorvsSilverSurfer08.jpg
He oneshotted surfer again in Infinity watch 23.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Prove Thor is more durable than Bill. Thor was weakened at the time. Just because someone can't counter that doesn't mean they are more durable. The board to the back didn't beat him his fists did.

That Doomsday ripped him wide open. I don't care he was powerful enough to cut through his skin.

A bug cut into Superman before. LOL. I can play the game too. Believe me.

Again, we debate how these guys are normally portrayed and the Surfer is more durable.

No, Superman can't. Thor's more powerful than Superman. It isn't even up for debate.

You claimed one shot.

You lied. Now I exposed you because unlike you I know what I am talking about. You're wrong a lot of the time. Submit to me like you did to galan.


Thor is more durable than bill on average.
Doomsday was adapting. He would cut surfer even more easily.

Which bug? Surfer is less durable than superman in general.
Its absolutely up for debate. Superman has done that.

Yeah and he oneshotted surfer.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Thor was beaten down before that by bill. Here is the oneshot
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Fights/ThorvsSilverSurfer07.jpg
http://i388.photobucket.com/albums/oo326/OneDumbG0/Thor%20Fights/ThorvsSilverSurfer08.jpg
He oneshotted surfer again in Infinity watch 23.
They were fighting prior to so that's not a one shot it's a ko. You don't ignore all prior damage of those two fighting and say one shot.

A one shot means the fight ended with one attack. That clearly didn't happen here.

Originally posted by quanchi112
They were fighting prior to so that's not a one shot it's a ko. You don't ignore all prior damage of those two fighting and say one shot.

A one shot means the fight ended with one attack. That clearly didn't happen here.


That fight was interrupted and bill beat down thor's ass. He oneshotted surfer who was all pissed and blah, blah, blah while going all out. Yeah, it happened the same. Warlock appeared and saved a koed surfer's ass.

Surfer would probably just absorb everything the ring throws at him, and then what could henshaw do by himself?

Originally posted by abhilegend
That fight was interrupted and bill beat down thor's ass. He oneshotted surfer who was all pissed and blah, blah, blah while going all out. Yeah, it happened the same. Warlock appeared and saved a koed surfer's ass.
So you believe all prior damage just goes away and any ko can be a one shot. I wonder what goes on in your mind for day to day activities. This is just plain stupid.

Originally posted by quanchi112
So you believe all prior damage just goes away and any ko can be a one shot. I wonder what goes on in your mind for day to day activities. This is just plain stupid.

Thor was beaten more badly than surfer and surfer had time to recover his energy. He didn't show any type of injury in the second fight. Yeah, it was a oneshot.
Originally posted by TheMask
Surfer would probably just absorb everything the ring throws at him, and then what could henshaw do by himself?

There is more chance that hank drains surfer via tech than surfer absorbing emotional energy from ten rings.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Thor is more durable than bill on average.
please stay on topic, this does not concern Cyborg SuperMan or Silver Surfer durability wise