If Batman had a Sinister Six who would be in it

I picked:
1.The Joker
2.Mr. Freeze
3.Bane
4.Man-Bat
5.Firefly
6.Poison Ivy

In no order:

Scarecrow
Croc
Mr. Freeze
Man-Bat
Deadshot
Poison Ivy

Joker is far too self centered to team up with other villains, imo...

Joker
Two-Face
Bane
Man-Bat
Catwoman
Killer Croc

Scarecrow
Two Face
Bane
Killer Croc
Deadshot
Penguin

I imagine Penguin as the leader in a mob boss/arms dealer portrayal of the character.

Croc
Freeze
Penguin
Man Bat
Scarecrow
Bane

would be my original Sinister six.

Assuming the Sinister Six would be vaguely analogous to Spider-Man's original Sinister Six, I'd say:

Mr Freeze (Octavius- tragic scientist genius figure).

Scarecrow (in place of Mysterio. The link's a little tenuous, I know).

Man-Bat (in place of The Vulture).

Killer Croc (vaguely equivalent to Kraven).

Clayface (clearly, corresponds to Sandman).

Maxie Zeus (Electro).

Joker
Scarecrow
Two-Face
Killer Crock
Hush
Clayface

1)Clayface
2)Killer Croc
3)Firefly
4)Mr. Freeze
5)Penguin
6)Ra's al Ghul (leader)

The Joker
Scarecrow
Two Face
Killer Croc
The Riddler
Mr. Freeze

I'd say Bane, but he was never a good team player.

Originally posted by Toku King
The Joker
Scarecrow
Two Face
Killer Croc
The Riddler
Mr. Freeze

I'd say Bane, but he was never a good team player.

And the Joker is? 🤨

Originally posted by Kovacs86
And the Joker is? 🤨

The Joker is when it suits his interests, and the other villains will deal with him when they know how impressive he is, despite his insanity.

Joker won't be in a Sinister Six because Batman's Six would cooperate together to make life hell for Batman- the Joker strongly believes that only he has the right to mess with Batman. This was scene multiple times in comics, and hell, even in TDK, he threatened to kill that dude who was gonna reveal Batman's identity. He would never agree to work with any other supervillain long-term, except for Harley Quinn. And hell, the Joker nearly killed her when she was going to kill Batman.

Batman's 'Sinister Six' would undeniably compose of six of Batman's lower a-list and b-list villains (no Joker or Ra's-al-Ghul-class, but no Calendar Man-class, either). I'm thinking either Black Mask or Penguin, Killer Croc, Two-Face, Mr. Freeze, Clayface, and Man-Bat.

1. Joker
2. Two-Face
3. Killer Croc
4. Scarecrow
5. Mr. Freeze
6. Ras Al Ghul(leader)

Ra's Al Ghul wouldn't be leader, the Joker wouldn't allow it. I know he's not a team player to begin with, but he'll kill for leadership, if he intends to be on the team, that is.

Originally posted by Markus Corvinus
Ra's Al Ghul wouldn't be leader, the Joker wouldn't allow it. I know he's not a team player to begin with, but he'll kill for leadership, if he intends to be on the team, that is.

Exactly... Either he's leader, or he's not in it... That's his mentality...

And Two-Face, I can't see wanting to join... He's got his own problems...

I just thought he'd be a cool addition, y'know, but he probably wouldn't join, unless he were really desperate to finish off Bats.

Originally posted by Bat Dude
And Two-Face, I can't see wanting to join... He's got his own problems...

If it involves "getting the Bat", he's in.

Originally posted by Master Crimzon
in TDK, he threatened to kill that dude who was gonna reveal Batman's identity.

When was that? I certainly don't remember that.

On TV, that guy who figured out that Bruce Wayne was Batman was going to reveal it. And then, while I mis-spoke when I said that the Joker personally threatened to kill him, but remember- he did stop the transmission by threatening to blow up a hospital if that dude wasn't killed in one hour.

1 - Scarecrow
2 - Black Mask
3 - Deadshot
4 - Bane
5 - The Phantasm
6 - Clayface