Current Thor VS. Superboy Prime

Originally posted by quanchi112
He destroyed a planet on panel with the guardian amp.

Destroying a planet takes more power than moving one out of its gravitational orbit imo.

Thor's attacks wont be ineffective. That is false. His hammer wil bring the pain.

Because ramming into something surely wouldnt be good,but it wouldnt start another big bang imo.

2. There is no opinion about it, it is factually more difficult to move a planet out of orbit.

3. Yes they will, to an extent, the magical aspects of any attacks will not hurt Prime, now, Thor's brute strength hitting Mjolnir on Superman Prime's face, sure, that might hurt, and I say might because SMP's durability feats like going through Anti-Matter or surviving a Big Bang are pretty damn impressive.

4. Hm. Just wanted to know your opinion. I won't actually use this point in a debate cause it is fairly ambiguous and unconfirmed.

Originally posted by Eel O'Brien
I checked and didn't see this fight.

Straight up, no special rules.

Prime will win due to popularity issues. Thor gets dogged way to much.

I almost lost my lunch when i saw the the most powerful version of thor (elder god) greater then his old self "Thor" and his father "Odin", loose to that red pille of crap.

im rooting for thor!

Current Thor is not greater than Odin.

He may have the Odinforce, but I don't think he has the runes.

Originally posted by Dark-Jaxx
[B]1. And without it. Whoa.

2. There is no opinion about it, it is factually more difficult to move a planet out of orbit.

Actually it depends on how much you move it. Just moving it into a slightly different orbit doesn't take as much energy, but throwing it into the sun or sending it flying off into space would take more than destroying it.

Of course we're talking about "moving the planet to another star system so fast that nobody even sees it until it gets there" levels, which is just ridiculous

Originally posted by Dark-Jaxx
1. And without it. Whoa.

2. There is no opinion about it, it is factually more difficult to move a planet out of orbit.

3. Yes they will, to an extent, the magical aspects of any attacks will not hurt Prime, now, Thor's brute strength hitting Mjolnir on Superman Prime's face, sure, that might hurt, and I say might because SMP's durability feats like going through Anti-Matter or surviving a Big Bang are pretty damn impressive.

4. Hm. Just wanted to know your opinion. I won't actually use this point in a debate cause it is fairly ambiguous and unconfirmed.

2.No,it isnt. Its just your opinion. Show me some proof tha suggests that moving a planet out of orbit is harder than destroying it under your own power.

3.No,it seems he is highly resistant to magic based attacks. There is nothing conclusive to prove he is completely immune to magic. Its only your opinion as usual. Surviving the universal blast are also opinion. Its my opinion Trapper pulled him out of there before that happened. A monitor also easily survived it,and those same Monitors can also be beaten by top tiers.
4. You have my opinion. Prime is an immature whiner who was upset he didnt get his perfect world. He overreacted and hasnt tried to do this since.

Look, Thor's magic isn't going to do anything to SBP as he's at the very least highly resistant against magic. Secondly, SBP has been shown to be stronger than Superman multiple times. When he got a sliver of sunlight he instantly threw off all the heroes that had attacked him. that included, MM, Wonder Girl, Powergirl, and about 100 other heroes. Also during GL 25 he had the advantage against PG, Superman, and everyone's favorite drill sergeant Kilowog at the same time. Thor's got nothing on him.

Originally posted by quanchi112
1.When did he destroy a planet on panel without it?

2.No,it isnt. Its just your opinion. Show me some proof tha suggests that moving a planet out of orbit is harder than destroying it under your own power.

3.No,it seems he is highly resistant to magic based attacks. There is nothing conclusive to prove he is completely immune to magic. Its only your opinion as usual. Surviving the universal blast are also opinion. Its my opinion Trapper pulled him out of there before that happened. A monitor also easily survived it,and those same Monitors can also be beaten by top tiers.

4. You have my opinion. Prime is an immature whiner who was upset he didnt get his perfect world. He overreacted and hasnt tried to do this since.

2. I can get it from Endless Mike next time he is on. I am pretty sure he has posted it.

3. Okay. Lemme rephrase this. SMP has shown to be immune to magic on a level higher than Thor's. I never said he was completely immune to all magic, in fact, I argued against that assertion with Red Hulk in another thread, although his resistance to magic is in fact very high. Prove Time Trapper pulled him out before the explosion, we have no reason to think that. A Monitor survived, yeah, good feat for the Monitor, not for Thor.

Can Thor survive a Big Bang now?

Originally posted by Dark-Jaxx
1. When he pushed one planet into another in IC.

2. I can get it from Endless Mike next time he is on. I am pretty sure he has posted it.

3. Okay. Lemme rephrase this. SMP has shown to be immune to magic on a level higher than Thor's. I never said he was completely immune to all magic, in fact, I argued against that assertion with Red Hulk in another thread, although his resistance to magic is in fact very high. Prove Time Trapper pulled him out before the explosion, we have no reason to think that. A Monitor survived, yeah, good feat for the Monitor, not for Thor.

Can Thor survive a Big Bang now?

2.I disagree entirely.

3.I disagree. Thor's hammer really didnt look that impressive against Rulk in their first encounter,but in their second he stomped him. I never concluded that the hammer couldnt hurt him.

I dont have to prove it. You havent proven he survived it. What does Thor surviving a big bang prove? Prime cant destroy the universe so I fail to see the point. I also said Prime as more durable. LOL.

My heart says Thor, but my mind says Prime.... so Prime takes this...

Originally posted by lionfranky
My heart says Thor, but my mind says Prime.... so Prime takes this...