Originally posted by truejedi
wait a minute, you can't put maul, Qui Gon, Obiwan on the same level as the B team. They proved, in their very few seconds onscreen, that they were NOT as good as advertised by in-universe opinions throughout the clone wars. Kenobi thought Fisto was better than him, then fisto gets butchered in 5 seconds, means kenobi was wrong. Mace thought htat saesse and Kolar were top duelists in the order, then by dying before they parry a single stroke, they too prove mace wrong.if this went to sabers, teh logicstics of a 3 on 1 fight is just too much to overcome. We have too much matrix, and lord of the rings from movies right now. In a real battle, aragon would have been dead over and over again. there are simply too many weapons to account for at all times to attack against overwhelming numerical odds in a melee fight. the movies we often see just show these attacks coming at perfectly timed intervals to allow the ehero , or villian to fight them off.
Sids owns this group with the force. Then its down to the old: Can he kill them quickly enough with the force to keep them from engaging him in saber combat. I think not, but very very close. All he has to do is kill one, thenm he can handle 2 of the others.
So you are saying that because they were killed by Sidious so easily they were no good? That is a very poor arguement.