Qui-Gon vs. Sarro Xaj

Originally posted by truejedi
it was a joke Crimzon.

Reported. Your trolling is too much.

[I'm joking, too. JESUS.]

Originally posted by Enyalus
Most of them learned Niman, and only Niman. That's an order of 10,000 strong basically running around knowing 'The Diplomat's Form'...come on. Logically, they can't be the prime of the Jedi in regard to lightsaber combat.

And Jango Fett is human. He was adopted by Mandalorians, but he's human.

He was a stronger and more skilled fighter than most Mandalorians. Dooku even acknowledged this.

Originally posted by Master Crimzon
Reported. Your trolling is too much.

[I'm joking, too. JESUS.]

obviously 😎

1. Saro
2. I have no idea, Rot did not tell us Saro's force abilities
3. Saro.

You base this on what, Skywalker?

While Sarro is a damned fine duelist-he was able to take Zannah and BM or no BM, he's just plain better than her- but Qui-Gon was considered one of the finest of his day

Originally posted by Lightsnake
You base this on what, Skywalker?

Originally posted by Gideon
Based on feats, narration, and general context

Originally posted by Lightsnake
Feats, narration and context.

Originally posted by Lightsnake

While Sarro is a damned fine duelist-he was able to take Zannah and BM or no BM, he's just plain better than her- but Qui-Gon was considered one of the finest of his day

Sarro is also 'considered one of the finest of his day'. He was an apprentice to a Weapons Master, and was well on his way to attaining that rank. Sarro was also in better physical condition than Qui-Gon, and I'd be willing to say better condition than Darth Maul. Qui-Gon struggles in extended, strenuous duels. Sarro may be able to wear him down.

this thread doesn't say TPM Qui-Gon red. If it did, that would make a difference, but when they are not assigned a designation, we assume, in their prime.

We have no feats of 'Qui-Gon in his prime'. We know that he's better, but by how much?

I've not read the TPM novel, so if you can quantify it feel free.

Sarro was better than Zannah. It might have been from the force boost from that one master (can't remember his name), but he still was taller and more muscular than Bane, and was beating Zannah.

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
We have no feats of 'Qui-Gon in his prime'. We know that he's better, but by how much?

I've not read the TPM novel, so if you can quantify it feel free.

Just to clarify, I meant that Qui-Gon from before TPM was better than his movie incarnation. I still think that Sarro takes this.