Silver Surfer's H2H Gauntlet

Originally posted by abhilegend
That he was on the planet longer than Hulk and was gaining in power since then?

Wut? Surfer arrived on Sakaar months ago than Hulk. He said he was there for months in IH 95.

Have you even read the comic?

No, its not. He was prevented from using PC. Its not the same as he was drained of them.

And you didn't answer mine: Why is it a good showing when all he did was beat on weakened warbound and got his ass handed to him by Hulk?

Also, after Surfer was freed and had his PC back, he still specifically said he was too weakened. This means Surfer wasn't recovered like you claimed:

"Still I am too weak"
http://s118.photobucket.com/user/bigbran1/media/Superman/IncredibleHulk95-022.jpg.html

No access to the PC means he couldn't amp his strength or charge his fist or do anything really, including recover. Unlike Hulk, he doesn't have a natural healing factor. Whenever Surfer heals himself or recovers his power he needs to actively us his PC to do it, which he was cut off from.

The answer to your question lies in the answer to mine: Why did Hulk and his warbound break Surfer's disc instead of simply knocking him out?

Simple question.

Originally posted by One-Punch
I have IH #95 and it doesn't say anywhere that Surfer was there for months, nor does it say he was there before Hulk. Don't make blanket statements, provide the page number or scan to back up your claim.

He was there for quite some time as he had fought in the arena before.

Also, after Surfer was freed and had his PC back, he still specifically said he was too weakened. This means Surfer wasn't recovered like you claimed:

"[b]Still I am too weak"
http://s118.photobucket.com/user/bigbran1/media/Superman/IncredibleHulk95-022.jpg.html

Like I said nobody claimed he was at full power. Neither was the hulk.

No access to the PC means he couldn't amp his strength or charge his fist or do anything really, including recover. Unlike Hulk, he doesn't have a natural healing factor. Whenever Surfer heals himself or recovers his power he needs to actively us his PC to do it, which he was cut off from.

It didn't cut him off from his powers.

The answer to your question lies in the answer to mine: Why did Hulk and his warbound break Surfer's disc instead of simply knocking him out?

Because apparently Hulk was surprised.

"Surprised by his former Ally's attack, Hulk recovered and shattered his controlling device but nonetheless angrily beat him senseless."

Simple question. [/B]

Simple answer.

Originally posted by abhilegend
He was there for quite some time as he had fought in the arena before.

Like I said nobody claimed he was at full power. Neither was the hulk.

That's not what Obedience Disk does. It merely subjugated his free will and turned him into a slave.

It didn't cut him off from his powers.

Because apparently Hulk was surprised.

"Surprised by his former Ally's attack, Hulk recovered and shattered his controlling device but nonetheless angrily beat him senseless."

Simple answer.

So you're saying the Odedience disc doesn't prevent Surfer from accessing his PC, even though Surfer literally states that's what it did?

😂

I'm not surprised you would dodge the question by posting an irrelevant summary of what happened. It's interesting you post everything except the actual comic.

There was a specific reason they destroyed the disc:

"Give him one more pass and we're DEAD. I only see one spot"

So in other words, an extremely weakened Surfer who had no access to PC was going to kill Hulk and the Warbound if they didn't break his mind-control.

This is based on the actual comic, not some summary.

Originally posted by One-Punch
How about you provide the page number or scan where it says Surfer has been on the planet for months? I'm not asking for your opinion, I'm asking you to provide proof.

He arrived at Sakaar quite some time before Hulk. As he was already champion of Arena before Hulk.

Hulk was already on sakaar for weeks.

So you're saying the Odedience disc doesn't prevent Surfer from accessing his PC, even though Surfer literally states that's what it did?

It didn't allow him to use it. It didn't drain him out. FFS here is Surfer using his blasts while wearing a control disc when Skaar implanted him with it.

I'm not surprised you would dodge the question by posting an irrelevant summary of what happened. It's interesting you post everything except the actual comic.

It's quite clear why he destroyed the disc. He wanted to beat his ass down.

Which is what he did.

There was a specific reason they destroyed the disc:

"Give him one more pass and we're DEAD. I only see one spot"

Hiroim using hyperbole isn't some kind of absolute truth. Unless you think Surfer can kill hulk in h2h when Hulk quite literally beat him into ground and had to be stopped from killing him..

It's nothing different than a lip service like "Martian Manhunter is so dangerous" shortly before random villain owns his ass and Superman has to save him.

So in other words, an extremely weakened Surfer who had no access to PC was going to kill Hulk and the Warbound if they didn't break his mind-control.

Hahaha, this is like arguing with a Martian manhunter fanboy. Hulk made Surfer his ***** AFTER he broke the control disc which should make him more powerful IYO.

But a less powerful surfer IYO is going to kill hulk?

crylaugh

This is based on the actual comic, not some summary.

Yes, where Surfer's attacks had no effect on Hulk while Hulk beat Surfer into ground.

Sure.

bump...and SS clears it

No, he doesn't.

Originally posted by Genii96
bump...and SS clears it

Just let those threads die, ffs.

^^^^^but they are so much fun

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Just let those threads die, ffs.

Hey what ever happened to all those Superman threads from like two weeks ago? I can't find any of them.

Originally posted by Board Walker
Hey what ever happened to all those Superman threads from like two weeks ago? I can't find any of them.

You mean the ones we've carvbumped? Bada closed them and erased our posts, lol.

Good to see you're back, btw.