Alan Moore Vs. The Watchmen

Blight Less than Newbie

Who wins

(Dear Mod's,

You can totally delete my other thread of the exact same title)

skyfather Bad Ass

[/thread]

Philosophía "The devil made me do it"

Maybe.

Blight Less than Newbie

Originally posted by skyfather
[/thread]

Whatever man, the Mod's love me! This thread will NEVER END!!

Blight Less than Newbie

Maaaaaaaaaaybe I was wrong?

Kris Blaze Restricted

I'd rather piss off fictional characters than a batshit insane writer, so I won't watch it.

Blight Less than Newbie

Post it in the poll.

Kris Blaze Restricted

Originally posted by Blight
Post it in the poll.

I don't think I will, now ahah

Blight Less than Newbie

Alright then.

iceman24567 Senior Member

😐

Blight Less than Newbie

I do believe that Alan Moore's book does things that are beyond the realm of film. But at the same time it would be really hard to miss out on the opportunity to watch a piece of art in action.

Kris Blaze Restricted

Originally posted by Blight
I do believe that Alan Moore's book does things that are beyond the realm of film. But at the same time it would be really hard to miss out on the opportunity to watch a piece of art in action.

Exactly.

Scoobless sselboocS

Originally posted by Blight
I do believe that Alan Moore's book does things that are beyond the realm of film.

Really? I don't believe that at all.

WrathfulDwarf THE LOOSE CANNON

Watchmen>Alan Moore's bloated ego.

Blight Less than Newbie

Originally posted by Scoobless
Really? I don't believe that at all.

Why? You can't put Pulp Comics into a film, nor can you do the expansions (IE Rorschach's File, excerpts from a fictional biography on a retired superhero [The Original Nite-towl(Thank you Kris)], The opinion of a philosopher on the concept of a man becoming god, & Excerpts from a ficitional Ornathology book that detail key things that coincide with the story of the Watchmen) in a film as well.

Zach Snyder even said he wasn't putting "The Black Freighter" into the movie, but instead as a short on the DVD, This STILL isn't a pulp comic book.

Terry Gilliam was stated as saying the only way the movie could be really made was for it to be 8 hours long. I don't believe the STORY would take 8 hours to create, but I also don't believe that given ANY amount of time, you could do the things done in the watchmen.

Moore Created a world with all the different side creations.

I will still be seeing the movie, though.

[edit] This is NOT me stroking the ego of Alan Moore, and I won't say that if you don't like it you just don't get it. These are the reason's I like the book.

I truly do think that this comic book redefined the Comics Genre.

Kris Blaze Restricted

It's spelled Nite-Owl, not night.

Blight Less than Newbie

Edited.

Kris Blaze Restricted

Originally posted by Blight
Edited.

I corrected the shizzle out of you 131

Comic wins 313

iceman24567 Senior Member

Lulz.

Blight Less than Newbie

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
I corrected the shizzle out of you 131
Comic wins 313

You Double-you tee eff poned me!

Will YOU be seeing the movie?