New Gods vs. Cosmic Powers

Started by Naija boy4 pages
Originally posted by guy222
thanos' team

Originally posted by iceman24567
That dummy fought about a dozen super powered beings at one time. Lets look at what the team consisted of Sentinel Allan Scott, Thunderbolt, Kc Supes and Starman i just think he was over powered nobody but a high skyfather would stand a chance against what Gog fought.
The first 'herald' 3rd World Gog had during the recent JSA arc, fought [and held his own against] the same peeps + quite a few more. Said 'herald' also fought Infinity Man, who was the prime agent of the Source at the time, and seemingly got the better of him in their few-page battle. Yet 3rd World Gog was ultimately beaten by the same characters [less than, actually] his 'weaker' herald was stalemating/owning? Weird, I say.

Geoff just won't write characters on consistent, or sometimes even logical powerlevels.

That's just it, and it f*cking annoys me.

Originally posted by Galan007
That's just it, and it f*cking annoys me.

Same here.

It doesn't sound any different than Galan and Surfer during Annihilation.
Sometimes the herald looks better than the Boss.

Originally posted by Avlon
It doesn't sound any different than Galan and Surfer during Annihilation.
Sometimes the herald looks better than the Boss.
But in the case I mentioned, the herald was better than the boss [or seemingly so, at least]

Originally posted by Galan007
But in the case I mentioned, the herald was better than the boss [or seemingly so, at least]

Gog basically jobbed the entire time. He Talked the entire fight. he could have simply removed everyone's sight.

New gods are over 30 years old, not so new, change the title of the thread, or be warned. This, itself, is a warning. 🪩

Originally posted by fangirl101
Gog basically jobbed the entire time. He Talked the entire fight. he could have simply removed everyone's sight.
I don't care what Gog might have been able to do, I'm talking about what he actually did [ie. feats] - and in that area, he just wasn't the proverbial 'cat's meow' imo.

Like I said, his first herald impressed me more than he did.

Originally posted by Galan007
I don't care what Gog might have been able to do, I'm talking about what he actually did [ie. feats] - and in that area, he just wasn't the proverbial 'cat's meow' imo.

Like I said, his first herald impressed me more than he did.


Well in this forum, we do go by what he could have done. Since he actually did Remove the very sight of the Dr. that he gave. It was in his power to do a many things. He simply talked thru the fight. His power may also have to do with the level of worship that he had at the time.

Originally posted by iceman24567
That dummy fought about a dozen super powered beings at one time. Lets look at what the team consisted of Sentinel Allan Scott, Thunderbolt, Kc Supes and Starman i just think he was over powered nobody but a high skyfather would stand a chance against what Gog fought.
I read the arc. he wasn't impressive in the least. The original gog in this arc when it first began did more damage. This guy was easily taken care of.
Originally posted by Mindset
👆

Gog was a scrub.

Yeah,they built this story up and then the heroes easily waxed him at the end. They kinda dropped the ball there. Overall a good arc though.

Originally posted by cloud102
Didn't he use his gravity powers, so people can attack him freely?
Yeah while Sentinel Alan Scott had a giant chain construct holding him with people all with super human strength pulling it Kc Superman, Power girl and a couple weaker people. Point is Starmans powers and a couple class 100+ characters held him down while the others blasted him. I really don't see anybody below the highest skyfather fending that off ❌. Yeah he totally got pwned but alot would fall to that team.

Originally posted by fangirl101
Well in this forum, we do go by what he could have done. Since he actually did Remove the very sight of the Dr. that he gave. It was in his power to do a many things. He simply talked thru the fight. His power may also have to do with the level of worship that he had at the time.
Originally posted by Galan007
I don't care what Gog might have been able to do, I'm talking about what he actually did [ie. feats] - and in that area, he just wasn't the proverbial 'cat's meow' imo.

Like I said, his first herald impressed me more than he did.

🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
I read the arc. he wasn't impressive in the least. The original gog in this arc when it first began did more damage. This guy was easily taken care of.
3rd World Gog was *somewhat* impressive, but nowhere near as impressive as he should've been, imo.

In short, I give most of this post a "👆"

Originally posted by Galan007
🙂

3rd World Gog was *somewhat* impressive, but nowhere near as impressive as he should've been, imo.

In short, I give most of this post a "👆"


I don't care that you don't care. In the Vs. Forum we discuss all of the time what a character might do. As I said, he simply talked too much. Even then, It was still the JSA with Thunderbolt. Even the original Gog herald didn't actually fight thunderbolt.

Originally posted by fangirl101
I don't care that you don't care.
That's not nice. 🙁

I care about you! 🙂

Originally posted by fangirl101
In the Vs. Forum we discuss all of the time what a character might do.
There's nothing wrong with discussing character potential. However, trying to use unseen power against on panel feats, is a faulty line of logic.

Like I said before, based on feats, the first herald of Gog seemed more impressive than the actual Gog [which is ridiculous, I agree.]

Originally posted by fangirl101
As I said, he simply talked too much. Even then, It was still the JSA with Thunderbolt. Even the original Gog herald didn't actually fight thunderbolt.
Okay, Thunderbolt only blasted 3rd World Gog two different times [neither of which did much at all]:

1.)

2.)

And just because said blasts came from a 5-D Genie, doesn't mean they were teh uber universe-busterz!!

Seeing 5th dimension beings being treated as cannon fodder makes me want to slap Geoff.

Originally posted by Galan007
That's not nice. 🙁

I care about you! 🙂

There's nothing wrong with discussing character potential. However, trying to use unseen power against on panel feats, is a faulty line of logic.

Like I said before, based on feats, the first herald of Gog seemed more impressive than the actual Gog [which is ridiculous, I agree.]

Okay, Thunderbolt only blasted 3rd World Gog two different times [neither of which did much at all]:

1.)

2.)

And just because said blasts came from a 5-D Genie, doesn't mean they were teh uber universe-busterz!!


falty Logic. It was the combined assault on Gog that contributed to his demise. To say the blast didn't do much at all is faulty. Obviously they did have an effect as Thunderbolt is easily the most poweful JSA member and before he actually got into it, the JSA had trouble with a simple herald of Gog. And as for discussing powers, I didn't mention anything that God hadn't shown. Gog gave the dr. sight, he also removed his sight. So where in the heck you get off saying I am discussing imaginary powers is beyond me. I simply said Gog, could have removed everyone's sight.

Originally posted by Philosophía
Seeing 5th beings being treated as cannon fodder makes me want to slap Geoff.
But in all fairness, T-bolt is hardly ever treated as a true 5-D Imp [no matter who's writing him.] 👇

Originally posted by fangirl101
falty Logic. It was the combined assault on Gog that contributed to his demise. To say the blast didn't do much at all is faulty. Obviously they did have an effect as Thunderbolt is easily the most poweful JSA member and before he actually got into it, the JSA had trouble with a simple herald of Gog. And as for discussing powers, I didn't mention anything that God hadn't shown. Gog gave the dr. sight, he also removed his sight. So where in the heck you get off saying I am discussing imaginary powers is beyond me. I simply said Gog, could have removed everyone's sight.
facepalm