Final Crisis Vs DOTNG Vs Countdown

So now that Final Crisis is over, how do posters rate each book: Final Crisis, Death of The New Gods, and Countdown? Which book did you enjoy the most and which was your least favorite? Feel free to show your adoration or vent your rage.

How is it possible to love Countdown?

Originally posted by Bentley
How is it possible to love Countdown?

Hmm... good fight.

Voted last one, although DONG wasn't hate worthy... it was horse ass at worst.

FC (really liked it)

DotNG (kinda liked it)

Countdown (garbage)

Proudly hated them all.

Originally posted by I'm Bran
You don't have to love it, you just have to like it better than DONG and FC...

Hmm... good fight.

Voted last one, although DONG wasn't hate worthy... it was horse ass at worst.

I said it because there is an option of "loved them all".

Countdown- Trash
DOTNG- kinda liked it.
FC- ok but nothing special ,sub par comic to me.

As far as Countdown goes, there were only a few issues out of the friggin' 50+ issue series, that I liked. The rest wouldn't even make good toilet paper, tbh.

FC Liked it, nice job Morrison/Johns.
DTNG was alright
Countdown I didn't waste time with until the very end.

countdown, utter crap
FC-meh, below average
DOTNG, good

Countdown - Hated
DOTNG - really enjoyed
Final Crisis - wasted too much potential

Originally posted by Galan007
As far as Countdown goes, there were only a few issues out of the friggin' 50+ issue series, that I liked. The rest wouldn't even make good toilet paper, tbh.

✅ Trust me I've tried.....those darn staples.....

DOTNG was the best of out of the three IMO

DOTNG>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Countdown>>>>>>>>>>>>>>FC

I avoided the other two but I did get FC and it was horrible.

Blackest Night will stomp these three storylines.

😂 DTNG/Countdown > FC. It was interesting seeing in Countdown Earth 51 then we get to see it in FC and Kamandi is taken prisoner and they talk about the Great Disaster.. This is the same planet the Omega Sanction placed Batman on. Not good news for Bruce 😑

Countdown was, at least after SMP appeared, very entertaining, in a Hulk -series kind of way.

DOTNG was an attempt at an epic closure to Kirby's New Gods, and though it wasn't fully succesfull, it was still above many stories.

Final Crisis though, is a masterpiece, and shouldn't even be included with the others.

We can talk about this in the discussion threads for these events. We don't need separate vs. threads for related events, especially because of the precedent it would set, and how we'd soon have too many of them (we already have 1 more recent one, far less relevant than even this).