Placidity
Chief Executive Officer
Strength
- Spider-man has plenty of strength feats going for him and I've talked about them over many of the Spider-man related topics, so I really cbs listing them again. But I think most people is aware of his incredible strength anyway (e.g stopping the train).
- Smith on the other hand, does not really have any strength feats to speak of, and the ones he does have, really pale in comparison to what we've seen Spider-man do.
Speed
- Spiderman over the 3 movies has shown some very good feats including the Flash fight scene, fighting Doc Ock etc. He has shown to be consistently fast in his fights and reaction time.
- Smith has his few moments of speed, but he has only shown to use it when dodging bullets (and also one instance during the subway fight, but never again). This is true even for the "Upgraded" agents. While doing this special speed move, he is indeed much faster than Spider-man, but given that it's something he can't do all the time, I'd give Spider-man the overall speed advantage. If the agents could move like that all the time, then the fights between agents and the rebels shouldn't last more than a second, and yet they do, and they don't use it during H2H fights...
Then there's also that Spider-sense, which may nullify any speed advantage (not that there is any) that the agents have.
Also a very important comparison would be Smith being killed by the train in the subway station. In an almost exactly the same situation, Spiderman is punched (by Sandman) onto the train tracks with an oncoming train. In this instance, Spider-man may have even less time to respond, yet his speed and agility allows him to escape death comfortably.
Durability
Spider-man is the outright winner in this department in my opinion. His arms has endured a tension force from stopping the train that surely would've ripped Smith's arms off. He also recovers very quickly from blows from opponents as strong or stronger than he is. Imagine this, who between Spider-man and Agent Smith would survive a full powered punch from Venom to the head? Or constantly being pounded by a giant Sandman, who's fist must have weighed many tonnes? Its like having a bus (maybe I'm understating...well at least something as heavy as a bus, thats just the weight of the fist, doesn't factor in Sandman's strength) dropped on you over and over again.
Other Advantages:
Pro Spider-man: Spider-man is also extremely agile, and will not fight like normal Martial Artists. He will have a style similar to Yoda's fight vs Doku where he is jumping around, sticking to ceilings etc.
Pro Spider-man: Spider-man also has webbing, which Smith has no counter to.
Pro Smith: Smith has presumably, like the Rebels, programmed every known martial art and skill into him.
. . .
Verdict
Overall, I would give Spider-man a dominating win.