Team two, and without much efforts. I always thought about it like this, the two worst people to EVER team up is silver surfer and thor. They are by far two of the most versatile and most powerful top tiers in comics and having them together is overkill.
Team 2 9/10, silver surfer and thor versatility>>>>>team 1.
Hm,
it should be possible for Kyle to lift Thor Hammer with his constructs, right? Did Quasar try something simillar?
Anyway, I think that Thor would stalemate or hold off Superman long enough till SS beats Kyle. And I can't see SS and Thor, together, losing to Superman.
SS vs Superman is debatable, though I leand towards Supes. But still, SS would fight long enough for Thor beating Kyle.
If this would be Hal I would give it to team 1, so Team 2; 7-8/10