Heath Ledger wins Academy Award for his role as "The Joker" in "TDK"

Started by Master Crimzon2 pages

Exactly. While I think that Heath Ledger's performance was supremely memorable and one of the finest rendered villains in modern cinema, the value of a director in this should not be taken out of the equation. For example... do you think Heath Ledger's performance would've achieved the same level of credit had it not been for the tense and unnerving atmosphere that engulfs the movie every time he shows up? The cinematography, the score (the rising, static-like noise in particular), and the dialogue all help craft his performance.

Of course, this is perfectly acceptable; all great performances were helped by the people behind the camera. But still, it's impossible to forget Nolan's ultimate contribution to the movie. He was the genuine 'star' of the film, in my opinion.

All in all, I'd rather have seen TDK rack up nominations for best picture and director and have Heath snubbed than vice versa, although a perfect world would have both.

He's got it

Re: Re: Re: Heath Ledger wins Academy Award for his role as "The Joker" in "TDK"

Originally posted by Kazenji
Not really, The Nolan version of the joker captured the dark and sinister side of the Joker something like you see in The Killing Joke.

he partly captured it but it was no where near it in terms of quailty

Re: Re: Re: Heath Ledger wins Academy Award for his role as "The Joker" in "TDK"

Originally posted by Mother_Morphine
,Ledger was a shitty actor who just happened to be ready to die when he played the Joker, that is why the film adaptation was better than Nicholson and Romero, Ledger was ready to commit suicide.

How did you come to that conclusion and 'Ledger was ready to commit suicide' ?? what a load of crap

He was taking the right pills to deal with his sleeping problem but it was just the wrong mixture and to top it off with that Dr Parnassus they were using some machine to the enviroment cold and that did'nt exactly help.

Heath Ledger was a good actor, no doubt about it.

He would not have been nominated for the Oscar if he didn't die.

The fact that he was nominated for an Oscar for his performance in a COMIC BOOK MOVIE (have we forgotten that the only other comic book movie to win an Oscar before now was Road to Perdition?), which also turned out to be his final role before his death, becoming the second actor to ever win an Oscar after his death is all too much of a coincidence to be based on his performance alone.

I'm not saying that Ledger's performance was bad. I'm also not saying that comic book movies are bad. I'm saying that the Academy doesn't award these kinds of movies. Ledger's death created a huge bias for the Academy.

Nobody can pull off an awesome live action Joker like Heath Ledger.

Originally posted by Nemesis X
Nobody can pull off an awesome live action Joker like Heath Ledger.

That's what they said about Jack Nicholson after his Joker performance.

Jack Nicholson's Joker sucked.

YeEDIT

Originally posted by Nemesis X
Jack Nicholson's Joker sucked.

No it didn't.

Originally posted by Wolfie

I'm saying that the Academy doesn't award these kinds of movies. Ledger's death created a huge bias for the Academy.

At least it shows comic book movies can be done in a good way to be noticed by the Academy.