Whick comic book movies do you think are the best and worst?

Best: The Dark Knight and Spider-Man 2.

Have'nt we done this topic but it was in the comic book movies ?

Originally posted by Kazenji
Have'nt we done this topic but it was in the comic book movies ?

Probably, yes.

Best...Dark knight, Hellboy, Constantine, Spiderman 2, Road to Perdition, The Crow.

Worst...,Fantastic four Rise of the silver Surfer, Ghost Rider, Cat Woman, Steel, Superman 3 & 4

Best: Superman II, X-Men 2, Spider-Man 2, The Dark Knight, MIB 1 and II, and Sin City.

Worst: All adaptations of Alan Moore's works (including Watchmen), Hulk, Ghost Rider, Spider-Man 3.

Impediment dude you didn't like Watchmen? Why not?

Originally posted by Quincy
Impediment dude you didn't like Watchmen? Why not?

Because a, roughly, 40% adapted movie from the graphic novel with some great eye candy SFX can't compare to the graphic novel that is Watchmen.

The movie didn't suck, but it wasn't, at all, great, by any means.

I forgot to add 300 as a best film

Originally posted by Scythe
I have seen it, it was sorta funny, but I couldn't stand it toward the end.

It is hard to believe that George Gaynes was so hard up that he actually agreed to be in that film.

Originally posted by Wanderer11
It is hard to believe that George Gaynes was so hard up that he actually agreed to be in that film.

Haha, I know.

Originally posted by Scythe
Haha, I know.

Now it looks like is so hard up that he has got to do Police Academy 8!

Best: Spider-Man, Spider-Man 2, Incredible Hulk, Iron Man, Superman 2, The Dark Knight, X-Men 2 worst: Hulk, Ghost Rider,

Originally posted by WrathfulDwarf
With the exception of Iron Man....all Marvel comics movies.

thats for worst movies right? if so,I would agree with that.and yeah as someone mentioned before,Im sure this has been done a few times before in the comicbook section.

Originally posted by Mr Parker
Yeah those definetely got to be the worst.as far as the best?
Best:
Dark Knight
Batman Begins
Iron Man
Superman 1 & 2.

I was in a rush yesterday when i made this post so I forgot to mention another film in best catagory and a couple others for worst.
WORST
Spiderman 1 & 3
Batman and Robin
Batman Returns
Red Sonya
Supergirl
Sheena
Catwoman
BEST
Dark Knight
Batman Begins
Ironman
Superman 1 & 2
and Dick Tracy

Originally posted by Mr Parker
and Dick Tracy

I totally forgot about Dick Tracy. Great, great movie.

Howard the duck stoned

Originally posted by Mairuzu
Howard the duck stoned

For both.

I watched it as a kid, no idea how i'll think of it if i watch it now

Originally posted by Impediment
Because a, roughly, 40% adapted movie from the graphic novel with some great eye candy SFX can't compare to the graphic novel that is Watchmen.

The movie didn't suck, but it wasn't, at all, great, by any means.

I agree... but does that really make it worse than Spawn, Ghost Rider, Elektra, X-Men 3, Batman & Robin, etc.?

Excellent:
The Dark Knight

Great:
Watchmen
V for Vendetta
Batman Begins
Iron Man
Spider-Man 2
Blade II

Good:
X2: X-Men United
Blade
Sin City
300
The Punisher(2004)

Okay:
Daredevil
X-Men
The Incredible Hulk
Blade Trinity

Worst:
Superman Returns
The Spirit
Spider-Man 1&3
Hulk
Catwoman
Elektra