Originally posted by truejedi
One things Sidious definitly failed to do was stay in control of his lightsaber fight, even if he was faking at first. Without even using the ROTS novelization (which i believe is frowned upon here, no?) Mace KICKED the lightsaber out of Sids hands. You can't fake that.The DVD commentary on ROTS (that is acceptable?) has Lucas stating that Mace beat sidious with lightsabers. Sidious faked being too weak to continue the duel after the first lightning attack, he still obviously had the ability to attack, but there is no indication that he actually would have won without Anakin's intervention.
Or taht he would have lost.