Phoenix Force vs Dr.Manhattan

Started by leonidas3 pages
Originally posted by Mekrob
Haven't read Watchmen in a while, but did he have a blue cock in the comics?

doh

Originally posted by Mr Master
Phoenix has never directly erased anything from existence my good friend.

Phoenix amputated an alternate future via the extraction of Sublime,
so Sublime was the device there.

Phoenix nullified reality 15104 via the mind raping of Scott,
so Scott was the device there.

Scott made a decision that created that alternate future (15104)
in Here Comes Tomorrow,
just like it was Scott's decision that changed the HCT future.
(although grant it his second decision was manipulated by Jean)

But the power of creation/alteration of said future laid in Scott's mind.

How can she not have done anything directly and then in the next line you say she amputated a timeline? Either she did or she didn't, and we all know she did.
Amputate means to remove something by cutting it off, if she amputated a timeline, then that means she removed it from the the timestream, when things are removed from the timestream they for all intents and purposes do not exist, 15104 was nullified when it was removed, it's point of divergence was the Scott thing. The universe was wounded by the amputation, 150 years of it was removed, Scotts new decision did not nullify 15104, because it was already seperated from the megasystem, Scotts decision grew a new future for 616 which makes that decision the point of divergence between the two.

PF takes it

Originally posted by guy222
PF takes it
Agreed. Awesome sig Guy.

Originally posted by LordKaos
How can she not have done anything directly and then in the next line you say she amputated a timeline? Either she did or she didn't, and we all know she did.
Amputate means to remove something by cutting it off, if she amputated a timeline, then that means she removed it from the the timestream, when things are removed from the timestream they for all intents and purposes do not exist, 15104 was nullified when it was removed, it's point of divergence was the Scott thing. The universe was wounded by the amputation, 150 years of it was removed, Scotts new decision did not nullify 15104, because it was already seperated from the megasystem, Scotts decision grew a new future for 616 which makes that decision the point of divergence between the two.
You don't have any scans, you can't be right.