If this is "Revan juiced by the Star Forge", he wins. He's a better thinker, a notoriously powerful force user, and head and shoulders above nearly every fighter in his era. A lightsided Revan defeated a Star Forge boosted Malak canonically, so naturally if he's the one being boosted, his powers are bordering on insane.
Update: Found that two year old email where I asked Drew Karpyshyn about Malak's powers in KotOR:
I'n not exactly sure what you mean about Malak being powered up by the
Star Forge. If you mean from a gameplay or stats perspective, it's hard to
say. We gave him unique stats and abilities in KOTOR to make the end fight
more challenging, but it's hard to say we "boosted" them, as you never get
to see any baseline stats for him as a player. In that aspect the question
is really moot.However, from a story perspective I'd say he definitly gets a boost from
the Star Forge. One of the things that made it so valuable was that it was
a focus of dark side energy, and with all the time he spent on and
studying the Star Forge, Malak learned to harness some of that energy for
his own use. I like to think of it as his home-field advantage.Drew
I'd screenshot it for authenticity, but I'm too lazy right now. Suffice to say that Drew, while not single-handedly responsible for the game, wrote the majority of its story and all of its dialogue (Last I checked), so I'd consider his opinion to be relevant.
revan wins.Both cannon and logic suggest hes superior. But i also agree that anakin would put up a good fight,as long as he does not do a stupid stunt like he did against obi.
as much as i vote for vader,because he has the most midichlorian count,revan aslo would be just as strong,evn more soo. Actually more you think about it the more its hard to determine. How long did it take anakin to complete his training? And how aobut rerva,who did in weeks what other jedi could never do in years.
Originally posted by darthbane99
revan wins.Both cannon and logic suggest hes superior.
Originally posted by darthbane99
as much as i vote for vader,because he has the most midichlorian count,revan aslo would be just as strong,evn more soo.
Originally posted by darthbane99
Actually more you think about it the more its hard to determine. How long did it take anakin to complete his training? And how aobut rerva,who did in weeks what other jedi could never do in years.
Look guyze! Learning rate is now directly proportional to Force potential!