Doc Holliday (Tombstone) vs. Ben Wade (3:10 to Yuma)

-Both were very fast gun slingers. Doc took out Ringo no prob and Ringo was supposed to be real fast. On the other hand though, Ben Wade was not only fast, but accurate. He one shotted almost all that he killed. So, is Doc's speed too much for Ben Wade or does Doc fall to "The Hand of God"?

Doc ill or doc normal? 😛

Originally posted by Mairuzu
Doc ill or doc normal? 😛

Good question. Just for rules sake, I'll go with sick Doc, only because thats how he is portrayed in the movie. We can only "guess" at how more bad ass he was when he was actually healthy.

Which Ben Wade? Glenn Ford or Russell Crowe?

Originally posted by BruceSkywalker
Which Ben Wade? Glenn Ford or Russell Crowe?

Crowe

I'm your Huckleberry.

Ben Wade.

The Lunger performed while being half-dead, Wade goes down.

Hand of God, nuff said.

Lunger's still faster, when he killed Ringo, it was The Fist OF GOD.

Ben Wade has a cooler hat.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Ben Wade has a cooler hat.

Yes, because that's a completely logical train of thought for a versus thread. 🙄

I say Doc takes this, but it won't be easy.

Doc takes this, since Val Kilmer is a better actor.

Doc wins. He's fast, accurate, and has no fear.

Originally posted by Impediment
Doc takes this, since Val Kilmer is a better actor.

I disagree, kind sir, Wade wins because Crowe throws a camera at him 😄

Wade was fast enough to gun down his whole crew, people.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
Wade was fast enough to gun down his whole crew, people.

And in his past life, he defeated an Emperor of Rome...oh wait, that doesn't count here. Sorry. 😄

Im not familiar with Mr.Wade's activities, but totally applaud the originality of a Doc Holliday thread.

Depends I think, a lot on distance. Holiday didn't seem to be as good from distance. And we don't know how fast Wade can draw his gun. He can shoot crazy fast but it doesn't matter if he can't draw fast. If it's up close I'll give it to Doc, because he can draw fast and he pretty much shot Ringo from the hip if I remember correctly. Distance I give it to Wade, he's crazy accurate and a fast shooter, Holiday won't be able to headshot from the hip as he did at the end of Tombstone.

Originally posted by Sadako of Girth
Im not familiar with Mr.Wade's activities, but totally applaud the originality of a Doc Holliday thread.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?s=&threadid=504275