However... you just got my noggin working... your underlying point is that experience makes the thing, right? So I don't know what it's like being trans because I haven't got the experience of publicly being trans (me having GD apparently has nothing to do with it). Well, then by that logic... how could trans people be the actual gender they present as? Unless they pass perfectly. But I've passed perfectly before. So that means that I know what it's like being a woman, but not a 'trans' person, because you have to not pass to be trans by this logic.
What astounding knots one can tie themselves in with the famous 'lefty logic'!
Originally posted by Scribble
However... you just got my noggin working... your underlying point is that experience makes the thing, right? So I don't know what it's like being trans because I haven't got the experience of publicly being trans (me having GD apparently has nothing to do with it). Well, then by that logic... how could trans people be the actual gender they present as? Unless they pass perfectly. But I've passed perfectly before. So that means that I know what it's like being a woman, but not a 'trans' person, because you have to not pass to be trans by this logic.What astounding knots one can tie themselves in with the famous 'lefty logic'!
you already experienced some form of gender confusion, yet refuse to see that people could possibly not be confused at all, and in fact quite certain of their transgender disposition, to the point where they are willing to risk being beaten or murdered just for being who they are. as cis-male scum, i can grasp the concept; yet you cannot seem to even be willing to confront it
Originally posted by Bashar TegWhat? I never had confusion. I grew up with GD, do you know what that is? It's where you feel trapped in the body of the opposite gender. And people don't transition in defiance of opposition — they transition because they know they're going to kill themselves if they don't do it.
you already experienced some form of gender confusion, yet refuse to see that people could possibly not be confused at all, and in fact quite certain of their transgender disposition, to the point where they are willing to risk being beaten or murdered just for being who they are. as cis-male scum, i can grasp the concept; yet you cannot seem to even be willing to confront it
Where are all of your trans friends? I grew up around trans people. I speak to trans people and gender non-conformers all the time. You know-a da nada, cis scum.
Originally posted by Scribble
What? I never had confusion. I grew up with GD, do you know what that is? It's where you feel trapped in the body of the opposite gender. And people don't transition in defiance of opposition — they transition because they know they're going to kill themselves if they don't do it.Where are all of your trans friends? I grew up around trans people. I speak to trans people and gender non-conformers all the time. You know-a da nada, cis scum.
there you go trying to pull rank again. classic scrib
Seriously, angry dudes trying to beat you up for presenting female are way less scary than the bleak nihilistic self-murder drive of Gender Dysphoria. That's why transitioning is usually preferable.
There are people who dress feminine who don't have GD — by your logic, they know more about being trans than someone with GD! Your logic is abominable and shows that you know nothing about transgenderism.
Originally posted by Bashar TegSo why am I not allowed to pull rank, but you are? If I were black American, would you be telling me that I shouldn't be able to speak on the black American experience? Would that be 'pulling rank'?
there you go trying to pull rank again. classic scrib
Just use basic logic for once in your life, man.