Originally posted by Borbarad
Oh noes, Gideon. That can't be the case. Because in order to beat RotS Sidious, you need to be Mace or Yoda. That means DE Sidious can't do the job because he's neither Mace nor Yoda, which means he's weaker than his RotS self.And, of course, more obvious. Since statements present in a C-canon source can't simply be wrong, we also have the "most powerful Sith Lord ever" line.
Uh. If Sidious is the most powerful Sith Lord [b]ever, that means at all times, always, at any time and in any possible case. That includes past, present and future.So obviously, using Gideon logic, there is no way that DE Sidious can be more powerful than his RotS self. 🙄 [/B]
First, "history" is the line used by the New Essential Chronology.
Second, Sidious is Sidious. RotS, DE, and other colorful prefixes are merely indications of the passage of time. Same person, Nai.
Originally posted by ares834
Really I have no clue who would win the purely force duel but an overall would go to the team. First, Mace Windu manages to defeat ROTS Sidious, while he is not as powerful as DE Sidious, he is still powerful. Vader was concidered to be 80% as powerful as Sidious. Anakin, while not in "teh z0ne" is a bit short of his Vader incarnation putting him around 60% of Sidious, abd this is being far less than generous. Dooku pwns none "z0nage" anakin putting him around 70% the power of Sidious. Thus togther they alll equal 230% of Sdious, and this is saying Mace is equal to Sidious. SO unless DE Sidious is 2.3 times as powerful as his other incarnations he losses and he is defently not that much more powerful. One of the largest resaons is Luke, becomes the strongest force user and he only becomes twice as powerful as the movie incarnations of Sidious. Thus the team wins...
ermm
I know tons of faulty information bt it conveys my ideas.
Faulty information shouldn't be used to convey a perceived logical idea. The fact that you recognize this and use it any way disturbs me. But I'm technically retired, so oh well. You merely have to answer to Lightsnake for your crimes, my child.
Gideon
First, "history" is the line used by the New Essential Chronology.
Eminence
I don't think "ever" was even used in the NEC. The line was "the most powerful Sith Lord in history."
Gideon
Second, Sidious is Sidious. RotS, DE, and other colorful prefixes are merely indications of the passage of time. Same person, Nai.
Lightsnake
using labels like 'DE' and 'ROTS' is only for us to place them in a timeframe for convenience.
Gideon
ermm
EminenceWay to introduce new and original ideas.
Yeah...
Originally posted by Borbarad
Oh noes, Gideon. That can't be the case. Because in order to beat RotS Sidious, you need to be Mace or Yoda. That means DE Sidious can't do the job because he's neither Mace nor Yoda, which means he's weaker than his RotS self.
I think that he was only referring to the movies, otherwise Luke can't beat Sidious because he's neither Mace nor Yoda.