Originally posted by Incanus
Valar and Maiar and Men of Dunharrow. Immortals and ppl that are already dead, SO WHAT IF JADIS CAN KILL ANYTHING UNDER THE SUN!!!! THESE GUYS CANT DIE!!!!! PLUS MORGOTH CAN MAKE A SHADOW TO BLOCK THE SUN SO HA U NARNIA PPL!!!!
Valar/Maiar DON'T LIVE IN MIDDLE EARTH!!!!! They live in another land outside of it.
Originally posted by Incanus
Oh, and Aslan cant Armaggedon Middle Earth as there he is a plain lion =-p not a god like creature
Did you read the Cronicles of Narnia at all?
Originally posted by Incanus
Yes i have, and in the First and Second Ages, Aman WAS within the Circles of the World, so they DID live in Middle Earth. And in Middle Earth Aslan CANT be a god like thing because thats what Eru is =-p
We're not talking about the first/second ages.
And Aslan IS more than just a lion, sure he's no Eru but he has been shown to show powers that are pretty amazing.
Everybody seems to be forgetting Rohan. They have the best trained cavalry in all of Middle Earth. Even Telmarines wouldn't stand a chance against a Rohan charge. I'd also like to see a Minotaur fight a Uruk-Hai. Minotaur would be dead in a matter of seconds. Simply put, Middle Earth has better weapons, armor, training and more powerful Wizards.
I doubt Jadis could take out Gandalf.
Based on what, exactly? If we are allowing her access to her magic then she will be turning people to ash left and right. She's a flash-bang sorceress, Gandalf is a mover & manipulator. Active Magic > Passive application. Tolkien's universe does not compare favorably, in terms of power level, to most other magic systems.
Jadis powders him into tea.
Howeverthere is a chance that the Deplorable Word could be off use in Middle Earth. If that were the case Narnia wins.
look at the big guns on narnias side aslan and the kings and queens of old
and on lotrs side ,aragorn gandalf ,gimili legolas ,faramir (you are oh so lucky its only the third age morgoth and his balrogs would whip their asses) well lotr brings a savageness into it orcs go beserk in battle plus they have wyrms, (dragonkin)trolls and wargs elves will also hep and men of the east/west would ick ass i cant see narnia winning
Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
No, it's not. I'm don't know who'd win, but you're probably just saying that because you are a LOTR fan...I forgot to specify: this is Narnia at it's peak.
Narnia and LOTR are on about the same tech level, so no this isn't a spite unlike what some fanboys think. LOTR might win, but it isn't a WTF pwn.
okay if narnias at its peak that morgoth gets to join in and kill everything btw the nazgul would seriously kick ass peter would crap his pants by just looking at them
Originally posted by coolmovies
Lotr would win 10,000 strong hold army
The entire population of Orcs, Gondor at its prime, Rohan's cavlary, the infantry of Rhun, the Mumakil of the Southerners, the elves of Lorien and Mirkwood, the Dwarves of Erebor and the Iron Hills, the various combatants from the rest of Eriador, a balrog, 5 wizards, 9 Nazgul, Sauron...
Sheesh. Numerically speaking, Narnia is f*cked. The main thing going for them is Aslan and the White Witch, who I doubt very much could handle all of that.
Originally posted by Lord Lucien
The entire population of Orcs, Gondor at its prime, Rohan's cavlary, the infantry of Rhun, the Mumakil of the Southerners, the elves of Lorien and Mirkwood, the Dwarves of Erebor and the Iron Hills, the various combatants from the rest of Eriador, a balrog, 5 wizards, 9 Nazgul, Sauron...Sheesh. Numerically speaking, Narnia is f*cked. The main thing going for them is Aslan and the White Witch, who I doubt very much could handle all of that.