Elektra vs Iron Fist

Started by cdtm3 pages

For the lazy:

Originally posted by cdtm

And yeah, Danny "cheated" in the end.

But look at this:

My favorite scene of the whole thing.

He disarms her, and instead of using them, tosses them aside. Rands a master of weapons, he knows how to use Sai.

A beautiful scene that establish's the difference between Elektra and Iron Fist. One is a killer, who does whatever it takes. The other is a warrior, with a code.

Elektra was heavily abusing the environment and going for the kill.

His wrist seemed to be fine after he had KO her.

In open grass field, Iron Fist would win.

you think? i'm not so sure. in a field she would have fought differently. he seemed physically superior, she came across as slightly more skilled to me. negligible differences though and a really well done fight that actually went the way it should have. nice to see.

Originally posted by leonidas
you think? i'm not so sure. in a field she would have fought differently. he seemed physically superior, she came across as slightly more skilled to me. negligible differences though and a really well done fight that actually went the way it should have. nice to see.

More nimble/adept, I'd say. Very resiliant, too.

He did disarm her, and while he she was punching him in the face, he was snap throwing her, which is all technique.

The main thing is, she was just relentless. I kind of think the Iron Fist was less a copout, and more because she simply would not stop, is VERY hard to KO, and without the IF he would be forced to kill her.

Which he had opportunity to do. Could have used those Sai's. Could have snapped her neck during that throw.

oh he needed the IF for sure--def not a cop out. but i'm not at all sure he would have been able to kill her had he not gone for it. looked pretty dead even to me and it could have gone either way imo.

Originally posted by leonidas
oh he needed the IF for sure--def not a cop out. but i'm not at all sure he would have been able to kill her had he not gone for it. looked pretty dead even to me and it could have gone either way imo.
except for the fact that if he had used the fist, the first time he punched her would've splattered her everywhere...

or she could have dodged it, (she couldn't dodge an aoe attack) but not sure what your point is. i said WITHOUT it i think it was pretty dead even and that he needed it to ensure his win. least that's the sense i got from the fight.

I get what you're saying.

How does Matt usually fare against her now?

The last time Danny beat "someone elses nemesis" was when he took down The Cat. Which was great, as a fan, but could also make Shang look bad, considering the best he ever got was draws.

Thank goodness nobody took it that way, but they could have.

The other side of that is risking making Danny struggle so much, he looks worse by comparison.. Another reason I credit Bendis, it's a tough balance to strike when characters face off outside their rogues gallery.

Originally posted by cdtm
I get what you're saying.

How does Matt usually fare against her now?

The last time Danny beat "someone elses nemesis" was when he took down The Cat. Which was great, as a fan, but could also make Shang look bad, considering the best he ever got was draws.

Thank goodness nobody took it that way, but they could have.

The other side of that is risking making Danny struggle so much, he looks worse by comparison.. Another reason I credit Bendis, it's a tough balance to strike when characters face off outside their rogues gallery.

i don't even know when the last time they fought was. in the past it's been pretty even though matt typically had the upper-hand from what i can remember. i don't recall a fight between them where he looked as roughed up as danny did, but i could be wrong. been a while since i looked at their fights.

A lot of Elektra/Matt fights have context. Usually him holding back, iirc, or mind/Hand control... I forget if that impacted her overall ability though.

She's looked top notch vs Wolverine on a few occasions though.

👆 she also made castle feel completely inept at one point.

Originally posted by leonidas
you think? i'm not so sure. in a field she would have fought differently. he seemed physically superior, she came across as slightly more skilled to me. negligible differences though and a really well done fight that actually went the way it should have. nice to see.
It was a very even fight, for sure, but Elektra did start off with two weapons in her hand [standard equipment, but still], and she was without both of them in moments, and Iron Fist even chose not to use them against her. Would he still do that in a forum fight? I get the no-killing, but not wanting to stab her should or something? I'm not so sure.

It depends on the fight but, generally, it's kind of a trope [at least in movies] that when somebody is winning a physical fight, the opponent starts pulling stuff from the environment - which is the same impression I got here. It could have been more blatant if she had hit him with the kitchen sink [lol], but still, she tried to impale him with the sais, slammed him over the head with the TV, tried to stab him with the knife...and at every step he was basically "I need no weapon". At the same time, the fact that he used the Iron Fist at the end maybe implied that he didn't think he'd be able to stop her in the normal way [at least, not without really hurting her - which he clearly wasn't into doing]. But in a forum fight? She'd probably get her limbs impaled quite soon.

Originally posted by leonidas
i don't even know when the last time they fought was. in the past it's been pretty even though matt typically had the upper-hand from what i can remember. i don't recall a fight between them where he looked as roughed up as danny did, but i could be wrong. been a while since i looked at their fights.

Hurt wrist against Elektra, broken back from Diamondbacks Batbreaker.

I'm not sure if Bendis is making these scenes to promote the character, or if he just likes beating him up and burying his intentions under flashy kung fu fighting. 😂