Jinzin vs OneDumbG0: Can telepathic blasts move at light speed or beyond

Started by ExodusCloak2 pages

Originally posted by gogogadgetgo
though i do agree that the speed of thought is instantanious, wouldn't the speed of thought be dependent on the person doing thinking? for example prof x and superman.

lets say prof x is powerful enough to telepathically control superman. but since he operates at a speed of normal human beings, his thought is slower than superman's thoughts and before he can actually finish thinking of control superman, supes would have already finished thinking of punching prof x and would have already reacted to his thoughts of punching prof x and would have already punched prof x.

or lets say that wolverine and silver surfer were both traveling at the speed of light and are both about to run into a planet in a 10th of a second. i have no doubt that the surfer would be able to think fast enough to evade the planet. but would wolverine be able to? before wolverine would have finished thinking of thinking to turn left, right, up or down or evade, he'd have already collided with the planet.

just my two cents.

There's a difference between conception and processing. A human and Superman should both conceive an idea at the same speed, Supermans processing speed however is greater then the humans though.

As for the thread. Speed of thought is faster or as instant as it gets how else does one explain Lilandra and Xavier telepathicallycommunicating over millions of light years without any lag. Quantum physics?? Dimension hopping?

BTW That Bolt Rachel used looks like something similar to telepathic lightning which is a different application of telepathy. It's like hardened telepathy something similar to what Psylocke uses to throw psi-daggers and Emma's psychic lightning that blew up a building. I wouldn't say that particular attack is being generated at light-speed. Much like you can dodge Psylocke's knives you can dodge that blast. Quicksilver did the same thing Exodus's psi-blasts (Potrayed as pink globules) he then opted for a non-hardened radial attack which was potrayed differently artistically.

Trust her, she is the Marvel telepathy specialist around here.

Xavier and Lilandra's telepathic link seems a bit different in my opinion.

Originally posted by Bentley
Trust her, she is the Marvel telepathy specialist around here.

It's him...

And it's an attempt at justifying Rachel's piss poor performance against Thor.

psionics are instantaneous. i.e. faster than lightspeed. the mind however, might be slower.

There's nothing conclusive showing that Rachel's attack's speed is as fast as normal telepathy. The stance is unsupported and based on speculation, not to mention the level of speed OneDumbGo is trying to imply goes against Thor's entire history. An overhyped feat, but impressive nonetheless. Besides, didn't Magneto react to and deflect Karma's attack from close range so that she posessed another one of her teammates ? (an attack that as far as I recall is similar to this one, ExodusCloak can most likely clarify things)

I enjoyed the hell out of the Jinzin/OneDumbGo debate from the other threads though, and I found both sides made a very good case.

Originally posted by Kris Blaze
Xavier and Lilandra's telepathic link seems a bit different in my opinion.

It's him...

And it's an attempt at justifying Rachel's piss poor performance against Thor.

Oh, I got confused. You can ignore him then 😛

Originally posted by jinzin
It is, I'm not doing this with him here and I told him that, close this damned thread.
You told me you wanted me to engage in this debate. You didn't tell me you would refuse to do it in another thread.

Anyway, you heard him. He doesn't want to do it. Close.