Herald-Level Slugfest Tourney · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

Starscream M Senior Member

Herald-Level Slugfest Tourney

Some herald-level tiers decided to have a contest to determine who among them was the best h2h fighter. For this tourney, the rules are that it is a purely physical slugfest (no weapons) and there will be no amping. Everyone fights at their base level.

Combatants:

Superman
Thor
Silver Surfer
Wonder Woman
Gladiator
Beta Ray Bill
Black Adam
Hercules (Marvel)
Sentry

Who will be 1st, 2nd and 3rd place?

Spire Senior Member

Supes

WW

BA/Glad

BRB

Thor

Herc

SS

Worthless

Juk3n Devils Advocate

Superman

BA/Gladiator

Wonder Woman

- the rest

wannabe P10 commercial Mindguard

Herc
Thor
WW
Supes
BA
the rest

Wild Shadow Restricted

wonderwoman
black adam
BRB
herc
thor

Harbinger Firestorm

Supes
Thor
Gladiator

Juk3n Devils Advocate

Originally posted by Wild Shadow
wonderwoman
black adam
BRB
herc
thor

you think Superman is below ALL those in straite PHYSICAL combat?

You're on Crack.

LOL at anyone who hasn't got Superman in their top 3 in this thread.

LOL i say!

Mindship Snap out of it.

Superman
Black Adam / Beta Ray Bill / Wonder Woman
Thor

wannabe P10 commercial Mindguard

Originally posted by Mindship
Superman
Black Adam / Beta Ray Bill / Wonder Woman
Thor

Whatever one rates the other ones, one can't rate Thor over Herc in pure h2h. The God of Thunder himself said, that he's slightly inferior in that department to the God of Power.

Wild Shadow Restricted

i just pick mine by actual fighting skill and killer instinct mentality of who would be willing of positioning and killing his opponent rather then get in a long drawn out fight.

and i believe WW and BA would kill superman if writers werent involved.
argue

Juk3n Devils Advocate

Originally posted by Wild Shadow

and i believe WW and BA would kill superman if writers werent involved.
argue

Based on what feats? 😈

Mindship Snap out of it.

Originally posted by wannabe
Whatever one rates the other ones, one can't rate Thor over Herc in pure h2h. The God of Thunder himself said, that he's slightly inferior in that department to the God of Power.

Interesting. And didn't Wonder Woman beat Herc (iirc)? If that's the case...

Superman
BA / WW
BRB / Herc

Philosophía "The devil made me do it"

Re: Herald-Level Slugfest Tourney

Originally posted by Starscream M
Some herald-level tiers decided to have a contest to determine who among them was the best h2h fighter. For this tourney, the rules are that it is a purely physical slugfest (no weapons) and there will be no amping. Everyone fights at their base level.

Fail.

Still, if only the strenght/durability (no speed) and 'give one take one' (not take one give 1000) rules are in effect, I'd rank them..

Superman
Black Adam
Gladiator

wannabe P10 commercial Mindguard

Originally posted by Mindship
Interesting. And didn't Wonder Woman beat Herc (iirc)? If that's the case...

Wasn't that in one of those very reliable and common sense following crossovers?

Mindship Snap out of it.

Originally posted by wannabe
Wasn't that in one of those very reliable and common sense following crossovers?

I believe so, almost right up there with Storm > WW.

wannabe P10 commercial Mindguard

Originally posted by Mindship
I believe so, almost right up there with Storm > WW.

Man, i choose Storm over WW anytime (though WW is pretty cool herself), but wasn't that a pile of bullsh:t?! 🙄

Lord Feron Senior Member

Re: Herald-Level Slugfest Tourney

Originally posted by Starscream M
Some herald-level tiers decided to have a contest to determine who among them was the best h2h fighter. For this tourney, the rules are that it is a purely physical slugfest (no weapons) and there will be no amping. Everyone fights at their base level.
Combatants:
Superman
Thor
Silver Surfer
Wonder Woman
Gladiator
Beta Ray Bill
Black Adam
Hercules (Marvel)
Sentry
Who will be 1st, 2nd and 3rd place?

Supes/Glads
Thor/BA
WW/Beta/SS
sentry
Herc

wannabe P10 commercial Mindguard

Re: Re: Herald-Level Slugfest Tourney

Originally posted by Lord Feron
Supes/Glads
Thor/BA
WW/Beta/SS
sentry
Herc

Again: Thor, according to his own statement and showing, is below Herc in pure h2h.

Mindship Snap out of it.

Originally posted by wannabe
Man, i choose Storm over WW anytime (though WW is pretty cool herself), but wasn't that a pile of bullsh:t?! 🙄

That's being kind. It could've been so much better if it hadn't been a popularity-contest rushjob. Some of the fights (eg, Spidey vs Superboy) weren't too bad. But others (Wolverine > Lobo also comes to mind -- Without Even Showing the fight!) were just... 😘

The best part of the whole series was the character stat pages.

snyper1982 Senior Member

Originally posted by Wild Shadow
wonderwoman
black adam
BRB
herc
thor

You really hate superman don't you?