KMC Contest of Champions- Marvel vs DC Discussion thread

I decided to go ahead and make a separate thread for this because it's gone WAY beyond my original idea in the other thread. I myself currently have no official say in how this thing's going to go down, but illadelph12 said that he'd host the thing. Here's all he's said so far...

Originally posted by illadelph12
After some consideration, I think I'll step back into an organizer role for now to get this thing moving and possibly participate as Zod or Apocalypse after everything is in place and someone else can take the helm. This idea has a lot of promise.

For starters, are their Team Captains for each company, and what will be the combat rules?

...so evidently there's no set format as of yet and everything's still up in the air. So everyone go ahead and throw in your two cents and lets get this baby going...

Smurph = Team Captain.

I'll bite.

so are team captains like the foremen of a jury, they get all the individual battle stratagems from their team members and puts them into a coherent initial writeup? basically just a poster willing to make sense of like 5+ posters hammering them with ideas.

right?

I have an idea that may be interesting:

-Each team will have a captain (of course) and a team of 6+ posters representing a certain character from their respective company. No quota on the number of members per team.

-Each week there will be a different battle scenario posted (for example, 3 vs 3 Meta Tier battle on Coruscant week 1. 2 vs 2 Herald battle in Manhattan week 2. 4 vs. 4 Street level battle in Tokyo, etc).

-Each team captain will designate a team from their roster to compete in that weeks battle scenario. However, this designation will be kept in secret and not known to the opposing side until the onset of battle.

-In the battle the posters representing each character will collaborate on a battle plan and debate the actions and interactions of their characters/team.

-No character can be used in consecutive weeks (to mix things up, allow everyone to participate, and up the ante on strategic planning).

We'll have to come up with a post quota, either collectively or indivudually, and time limits. It will be up to the combatants to strategize and coordinate their attacks, of course. Other team members can provide logistical support (researching their opponents for weaknesses, finding scans, etc) while their not competing. We're also going to need some neutral judges like myself. At least 3 per match. Also, it might be a good idea to schedule out the battlefields and and match stipulations (number of people participating each week) up front to allow the captains and their teams to come up with a week by week strategy and scheduling things out on each person's real life responsibilities.

Just a proposal, of course.

Also, we might want to have a poster draft unless ya'll want to keep the team from the original thread as Team Marvel.

😂

Have fun. Put me down for judge.

Heh.

Yeah, I know.

I like challenges.

Originally posted by Digi
😂

Have fun. Put me down for judge.

I don't think it's a lack of faith. It's more of an acknowledgment of a precedent.

However, with compromise and level heads, I think this could go off with relative ease.

without a doubt.

hey digi, does that mean adam warlock is up for grabs?

*i still want thanos though if that's possible.

If Ill is back on board, i see no reason to be involved in the organisation of it, as it's in good hands.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
so are team captains like the foremen of a jury, they get all the individual battle stratagems from their team members and puts them into a coherent initial writeup? basically just a poster willing to make sense of like 5+ posters hammering them with ideas.

right?

I was thinking more along the lines of the captains being spokespersons for the entire team and organizing things. They wouldn't necessarily have all of the responsibilities, but they'd be the primary liaison as far as presenting opening posts and making sure their teammates are on the same page and doing what's necessary to win. Those criteria can fall on more than one member of the team though. It's always good to have capable teammates.

As for the teams, do participants want a draft with captains making the picks, or to just freely pick a side and then decide who is the captain afterwards?

Originally posted by Raoul
If Ill is back on board, i see no reason to be involved in the organisation of it, as it's in good hands.

So you're going to compete as Cyclops or Supes (or Hamson)?

Originally posted by illadelph12
I have an idea that may be interesting:

-Each team will have a captain (of course) and a team of 6+ posters representing a certain character from their respective company. No quota on the number of members per team.

-Each week there will be a different battle scenario posted (for example, 3 vs 3 Meta Tier battle on Coruscant week 1. 2 vs 2 Herald battle in Manhattan week 2. 4 vs. 4 Street level battle in Tokyo, etc).

-Each team captain will designate a team from their roster to compete in that weeks battle scenario. However, this designation will be kept in secret and not known to the opposing side until the onset of battle.

-In the battle the posters representing each character will collaborate on a battle plan and debate the actions and interactions of their characters/team.

-No character can be used in consecutive weeks (to mix things up, allow everyone to participate, and up the ante on strategic planning).

We'll have to come up with a post quota, either collectively or indivudually, and time limits. It will be up to the combatants to strategize and coordinate their attacks, of course. Other team members can provide logistical support (researching their opponents for weaknesses, finding scans, etc) while their not competing. We're also going to need some neutral judges like myself. At least 3 per match. Also, it might be a good idea to schedule out the battlefields and and match stipulations (number of people participating each week) up front to allow the captains and their teams to come up with a week by week strategy and scheduling things out on each person's real life responsibilities.

Just a proposal, of course.

But that's just my opinion on the matter, feel free to disregard it if you'd rather not handle things that way.

Originally posted by illadelph12
So you're going to compete as Cyclops or Supes (or Hamson)?

i'm moving house, so i don't know if i'll have the time.

if i get back on relatively quickly, and you guys have kept it simple, i might give it a shot...

There was no hidden subtext in my last post. I was amused, wished you guys well, and offered to be a judge. The offer stands. I don't really have time to compete in anything atm, and anything tourney-related always needs reliable judging, so it's a win-win.

And yeah, Warlock's up for grabs. Feel free to take him, though there might be rules for 'calling' characters, so you might want to talk to goob or someone.

Originally posted by illadelph12
I have an idea that may be interesting:

-Each team will have a captain (of course) and a team of 6+ posters representing a certain character from their respective company. No quota on the number of members per team.

-Each week there will be a different battle scenario posted (for example, 3 vs 3 Meta Tier battle on Coruscant week 1. 2 vs 2 Herald battle in Manhattan week 2. 4 vs. 4 Street level battle in Tokyo, etc).

-Each team captain will designate a team from their roster to compete in that weeks battle scenario. However, this designation will be kept in secret and not known to the opposing side until the onset of battle.

-In the battle the posters representing each character will collaborate on a battle plan and debate the actions and interactions of their characters/team.

-No character can be used in consecutive weeks (to mix things up, allow everyone to participate, and up the ante on strategic planning).

We'll have to come up with a post quota, either collectively or indivudually, and time limits. It will be up to the combatants to strategize and coordinate their attacks, of course. Other team members can provide logistical support (researching their opponents for weaknesses, finding scans, etc) while their not competing. We're also going to need some neutral judges like myself. At least 3 per match. Also, it might be a good idea to schedule out the battlefields and and match stipulations (number of people participating each week) up front to allow the captains and their teams to come up with a week by week strategy and scheduling things out on each person's real life responsibilities.

Just a proposal, of course.

I nominate Smurph as team captain. He's plenty experienced with tourney-style matches, has demonstrated innate ability for tourney strategy, has a thorough knowledge of most things comic, and is, above all, modest.

313

As for the actual rules:

Post counts should be individual, ideally, since people will be repping different characters, and each should be heard equally. The biggest argument for collective time caps would be that some posters can't make post quota due to time constraints, but that's what we'll have so many characters for, right?

Each teammate should be required to be fielded at least once, assuming that we have a set time to end this by.

We should consider back up posters for certain characters, or back up characters for certain posters? Could be a mess, but if we really need Magneto for a certain match, and the Magneto repper is gone, it could help to have a sub.

Originally posted by Original Smurph
I nominate Smurph as team captain. He's plenty experienced with tourney-style matches, has demonstrated innate ability for tourney strategy, has a thorough knowledge of most things comic, and is, above all, modest.

313

As for the actual rules:

Post counts should be individual, ideally, since people will be repping different characters, and each should be heard equally. The biggest argument for collective time caps would be that some posters can't make post quota due to time constraints, but that's what we'll have so many characters for, right?

Each teammate should be required to be fielded at least once, assuming that we have a set time to end this by.

We should consider back up posters for certain characters, or back up characters for certain posters? Could be a mess, but if we really need Magneto for a certain match, and the Magneto repper is gone, it could help to have a sub.

off topic, but:

did you get that message i sent you on msn?

Originally posted by Raoul
off topic, but:

did you get that message i sent you on msn?

You know he just leaves MSN on even when he's not around. Then responds 6 hours later 😂

Anyways, Im willing to do this. Don't really care which side as I have favorites in each company. If someone wants me on a particular side, let me know through PM's or MSN.

And good luck Delph.