Aragorn vs Eragon (no dragon)

Gimping Eragon?

He loses probably. Though his sword is able to ignite in flames - could be a possible advantage. But probably not enough - Aragorn is stronger, and more experienced

for the record, if Eragon wasn't being gimped, Aragorn would be ****ed.

Eragon over Aragorn any day!

Eragon is stronger, faster, more durable, and an excellent swordsman...even gimped he takes a majority....people just don't like him though so he loses accodring to them.

Eragon is like the most OP protagonist of any major fantasy franchise. He wins no matter how much I want Aragorn to slice him to bits.

The guy learned to become a master swordsman from dueling with brooms with his brother and then training for a few days in the woods with his mentor.

Eragon can cut Aragorn's nipples off before he can even blink. And his sheer strength can blow Narsil right out of his hands. Curbstomp city.