Which is the best X-Men cartoon?

Originally posted by Pyron_Knight
Ya know, X-Men TAS had its legitimately great episodes. They tnd to be the parts people remember and talk about in threads like this.
Episodes with Apocalypse, Magneto, the Dark Phoenix Saga... That's some great stuff.

But there's a whole lot of crap in-between those great eps.

That's why i pick X-Men Evolution. It had better characterization and storylines overall and ya know what really made it? The fact the voice-acting doesn't make my ears bleed. Almost everyone iN TAS sounded awful in the extreme.

There's no way they could have done it of course but I missed Cable in Evo. That's one thing TAS will always have. Cable was all kinds of awesome on that show.

tbh i don't agree at all. the characterisation in TAS held better from the comics, and i honestly liked the voices better in TAS. Not saying that Evolution was bad by any means; in fact the show got better as time went on. If you were to take the totality of both shows and stack them, i honestly believe TAS would win, as Evolution took a long time to find it's feet and get going.

Plus, it had Spike. 😛

Without X-men The Animated Series there would be no Evolution, Not to mention Wolverine and the X-men.

TAS did come first, yeah, though that's not what made it better than the other two in quality (and quantity 😛).

And I liked Spike. At least during the last appearances he made when he was protecting the Morlocks. But yeah, out of all the animated versions of X-Men characters there have been, almost nothing beats Cable in TAS.

The voice actors in TAS were incredible/perfect.

Not all of them.

Which voice actor's characters didn't you like?

why the F did they change Gladiators voice ? he sounds like a total pussy now

Originally posted by the ninjak
Which voice actor's characters didn't you like?

Originally posted by Ridley_Prime
Off the top of my head, Rogue's,

* back then, i find Rogue's voice and accent very sexy... but in time, i found it very annoying... 🙂

Originally posted by Ridley_Prime
Gambit's

* the voice perse is fine, what i hate is the accent...

Originally posted by peejayd
* back then, i find Rogue's voice and accent very sexy... but in time, i found it very annoying... 🙂

Originally posted by peejayd
* the voice perse is fine, what i hate is the accent...

Originally posted by Ridley_Prime
Off the top of my head, Rogue's, Gambit's (although it sorta grew on me over time), and a couple others whose names elude me at the moment. Magneto also had a much cooler voice in Evolution.

God I love Rogue's voice. Throaty Southern. Each tom their own I guess.
I found Storm to be annoying but I still liked the choice.

X-Men: TAS. No contest.

And I liked X-Men: Evolution more than Wolverine and the X-Men.

agreed. WATXM annoys, big time.

Originally posted by -Pr-
tbh i don't agree at all. the characterisation in TAS held better from the comics, and i honestly liked the voices better in TAS. Not saying that Evolution was bad by any means; in fact the show got better as time went on. If you were to take the totality of both shows and stack them, i honestly believe TAS would win, as Evolution took a long time to find it's feet and get going.

Plus, it had Spike. 😛

The Logan wankage in Wolverine and the X-Men wasn't as severe as I thought it would be. For the run the cartoon had, I liked it, but not as much as Evolution. Probably would've liked it better than Evolution though had the Age of Apocalypse season not been canceled along with the show.

I voted for Xmen TAS because of Rogue. She was soo f*cken hot. When I was younger, I wanted to have a girlfriend that looked just like her. Anyway, I voted for that show because all of the characters except for Wolverine. The women looked beautiful, and the men had great physics (I'm one step closer at looking like Cyclops ) 😄... The episodes, the art and the voices were far better than the recent cartoons. However, I was pretty happy with Xmen evolution. I recently watched all of the episodes. But, didn't care for Spike, Avalanche and some of the episodes. Overall, both shows were great but Xmen TAS is the superior.

I honestly liked the hair and stuff Rogue had in Evolution and W&TX-M better than in the original series. The original TAS will always get my vote too, but not because of her.

X-Men TAS, but I will say that the animation and production value saddly just hold up as well as Batman or Superman TAS. It isn't nearly as good now as I remember it being. 🙁

And why is that? Maybe I'm less picky, but it wasn't that long ago since I last watched some of X-Men the animated series again, and thought the animation was up there with the Batman and Superman TAS, except for the last season.