Who's The Best Swordsman?

I still gotta see that.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Bah! I already know he's skilled from just the trailer.

From clashing swords and moving them about a bit?

I agree, he will obviously be portrayed as skilled, but still. Not much in the trailer.

-AC

Originally posted by jaden101
Without the force the jedi/sith would be heavily disadvantaged...I hate the stupid debates in the SW forums when people say "who'd win in 1: sabres 2: force 3: all out"...As if somehow their sabre skills and fighting ability were completely seperate from their force abilities.

then you obviously completely misunderstand what they mean when they say that.

wheres zatoichi ?

otherwise i'll go with Achilles or Mace Windu

The SWVF debates saying "sabers" mean Jedi/Sith using force abilitites like pre-cog and stats. No offensive force moves.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
I still gotta see that.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
Let's not forget that Zorro uses a different kind of sword: rapier. Jedi a lightsaber. Aragorn a longsword. Katsumoto a katana. We must take these into account.

The **** is anyone else going to deal with a lightsaber.

/end

Say they were all unbreakable against each other's swords. Who'd have the best skill and technique.

It has no bearing here, this isn't pitting them against one another, it's about who displays the best skills against their respective enemies.

True but it was a counter to his comment. The Jedi are hard to examine since they incorporate Force enhanced stats and pre-cog into there fights.

Then dont count them here?

So now we aren't taking them into account?

Then Kiddo or Yoda

Kiddo or Zorro.

Its not who bears best skills against their respective enemies... becuase that makes no sense at all to say whos the best swordsman... cause if thats the case... then the jedi are the best considering their enemies are always going to be the toughest. I would like to see zorro ****in kill a Sithlord.

Zorro literally fights dozens of soldiers at the same time. His opponents are very skilled as well. Sith Lords have abilities that would make them superhumans. Power cannot be considered skill.

Okay true Zorro has battled enemies with skills, but so has the Jedi. They parry better than almost anyone and not to mention they can go down 1 of 4 ways of the Jeid. Saber skill and training is one of them, and once you throw in the fact that like someone liek Yoda is hella old so he has had time to hone his skills

Yes but they are aided with the Force. Yoda can't fight without it. His lightsaber form requires the Force to aid him in battle.

Zorro requires no such help.

You're really trying to say? Yoda would not be able to swing a lightsaber without the force? That's just blasphemy.

He wouldn't be able perform at the level he does against Tyranus and Sidious without aid from the Force. You see how he's a slow old person without it when he's walking with his stick.

And if we're really going off of that then I can easily still replace Yoda and put Maul in. Like im telling u in the other thread. Maul was one of the best swordsman in the Star Wars existence.

I'm don't think Maul is as skilled as Zorro.