Dr. Manhatten vs. Dark Phoenix

Jean Grey is posessed by the Phoenix and goes on a rampage in NYC. Dr. Manhatten shows up to put a stop to it.

Who would win?

Manhattan, as he can reform himself if she somehow manages to destroy him. /end

Dr. Manhattan can control anything and everything.

She's just a psychic.

-AC

Just finished reading Watchmen, great piece of graphic literature, that. Wish I have read it a decade ago.

If you take the deleted scenes into consideration, DP can transmute matter, meaning she can disintegrate people at an atomic level.

Manhattan said he could reform his molecules, however, can he reform from disintegrated atoms?

The other thing is that DP's disintegration is at least molecular, but when Manhattan uses his TK to kill people, he just blows them up (you can see blood and stuff), which might lend to the notion that her TK can work on a more potent scale.

She may also be able to keep Manhattan from reforming.

Also, how does Manhattan cope with a Mind rape?

Just some points to consider/Getting the debate rolling... some of it speculation...

Manhattan is beyond humanity and mutant alike, he's an entity.

Dark Phoenix isn't, it's Jean Grey. He kills Jean Grey, the fight is over.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
Manhattan is beyond humanity and mutant alike, he's an entity.

Dark Phoenix isn't, it's Jean Grey. He kills Jean Grey, the fight is over.

Yea, I can see Manhattan winning. But your argument really isn't...an argument.

I don't care, that's the problem with Vs threads.

Arguments where there need be none. If someone obviously wins, they win obviously. Next thread.

Why does every fight have to be discussed if the outcome is clear?

-AC

Well I see what you're getting at. But here I genuinely think DP has the potential to pull some wins. Probably 1/10 though.

My point is; if you have to descend into rather retarded, non-sensical hyperbole to have a thread exist and make a discussion, what's it worth?

-AC

Shits and giggles?

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
My point is; if you have to descend into rather retarded, non-sensical hyperbole to have a thread exist and make a discussion, what's it worth?

-AC

I think the points in my argument are far from that... I'm sure most people can see some merit in them.

RJ, you're now known as Peter Pan.

Pete for short.

Originally posted by Placidity
I think the points in my argument are far from that... I'm sure most people can see some merit in them.

YOU are not specifically retarded, but you were clearly reaching into MASSIVE hyperbole for the sake of discussion. If you have to do that for there to be one, why?

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri

YOU are not specifically retarded, but you were clearly reaching into MASSIVE hyperbole for the sake of discussion. If you have to do that for there to be one, why?

-AC

What do you mean by hyperbole? I didn't use any...

Originally posted by Placidity
What do you mean by hyperbole? I didn't use any...

I think he's referring to the deleted scene/s as hyperbole.

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
RJ, you're now known as Peter Pan.

Pete for short.

-AC

You need alcohol, ALOT of it.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
But I wanna be Peter Parker. Can I please?

You need alcohol, ALOT of it.

Nope.

RJ, not all men have to drink beer. I know that in your bubbleworld where Rambo and naked chicks are the pinnacle of life, this may seem mind-boggling, but it's true.

-AC

Originally posted by Alpha Centauri
Nope.

RJ, not all men have to drink beer. I know that in your bubbleworld where Rambo and naked chicks are the pinnacle of life, this may seem mind-boggling, but it's true.

-AC

The beer is to loosen you up. I bet your rectum is more watertight than a newborn water moccasin's.

Naked chicks droolio

poor poor Dark Phoenix, she get blown to smithereens

Dark Phoenix....blown....... haermm