Jaina/Jag vs Anakin/Padme

Who:

FOTJ Jaina
FOTJ Jag no beskar armor

ROTS Anakin
ROTS Padme

What:

A fight to the death, bloodlust on

When: At noon, both sides have adequate knowledge of the other side and had 30 minutes to prepare.

Where: a casino

Why: You make it up

Surprisingly, this is a hard one to call. I'd put Jag above Padme, but Anakin would probably beat Jaina so I'm going to have to go with team 2.

team two stomps

Team 1. Jag would beat Padme and Jaina would eventually beat anakin.

Are there any feats though to prove that Jag > Padme? I guess that he has more combat experience.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
Are there any feats though to prove that Jag > Padme? I guess that he has more combat experience.

Uh, does Padme have any combat feats at all? Jag does have several throughout NJO, LOTF and DN.

Originally posted by Vorpal Ruin
Uh, does Padme have any combat feats at all? Jag does have several throughout NJO, LOTF and DN.

Ehm, she can hold a blaster the right way...

Originally posted by Slash_KMC
Ehm, she can hold a blaster the right way...

Originally posted by mattatom
Oh and she survived Geonosis.
Padme>Coleman Trebor.

She did have an Anakin covering her awesome back though.

Her cut up, awesome back.

droolio

Originally posted by Vorpal Ruin
Team 1. Jag would beat Padme and Jaina would eventually beat anakin.

Originally posted by ares834
Jaina would beat Anakin. 😕

Don't be confused. Just accept it.

EDIT: Sorry man, I forgot that you think Dooku and Galen have a better chance than Bane and Caedus at beating Sidious. I'm just not noticing the jokes fast enough. 🙁

Team 2

Jag kills Padme easily
Anakin gets pissed and kills Jag
Anakin in bloodlust kills Jaina

Although Jaina fought and killed Caedus, Caedus wasn't under the spell of bloodlust. Nuff said.

Originally posted by Darth Truculent
Team 2

Jag kills Padme easily
Anakin gets pissed and kills Jag
Anakin in bloodlust kills Jaina

Although Jaina fought and killed Caedus, Caedus wasn't under the spell of bloodlust. Nuff said.

So it's actually whoever wins in the blaster duel their team actually loses.

If Jag kills Padme (not "easily"; Padme is also pretty skilled and could just get in a lucky shot) then

Anakin in bloodlust kills the other team.

Else If Padme kills Jag then

Jaina in bloodlust kills the other team.

Tricky, eh?

Nice too, but Jaina is nowhere near the power of Anakin of ROTS. Anakin's Force abilities and his Djem So would overpower her lighstaber skill. Jag is a military man, so he would kill Padme easily because he is trained to use a blaster properly.

Well according to Lucien Jaina by LOTF had surpassed Obi Wan.

Who hadn't surpassed Obi-Wan by LotF?

Remember: Kenobi lasted against Anakin because of familiarity and Soresu. Jaina's not got the same advantages. Though in the Force, Jaina's got Kenobi whooped.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
Who hadn't surpassed Obi-Wan by LotF?

Everybody in the jedi order except for some of the high council members and (according to you) Jaina.

If by LOTF every jedi had surpassed Obi Wan, then wouldn't LOTF be the prime of the jedi and not the PT "prime" era because in the PT 9997/10000 of the Jedi would get pwned by Obi Wan?

Hey Obi-Wan isn't a weakling either!

He has godly force-push powers. lol.

And he defeated a room full of droids while intoxicated. (as in drunk)

so the proper term would be DWI (destroying while intixicated) 😄

This is true btw, Its in a clone wars book. But not sure which one.

And, Jaina's force powers are retarded compared to Anakins force powers. She may have more abilities, (such as shatterpoint) but Anakin's strength in the Force would offer him more endurance.

Note: Caedus's weak one handed force lightning always screwed Jaina over. I would imagine Anakin's force scream that brought down a roof could do the same if not more...

Originally posted by kotorfan
And he defeated a room full of droids while intoxicated. (as in drunk)

so the proper term would be DWI (destroying while intixicated) 😄

This is true btw, Its in a clone wars book. But not sure which one.

It was Labyrinth of Evil I think.