The Adamantium Sword Challenge

Originally posted by SoulDevourer
uh no mjolnir is harder
mjolnir has dented adamantium

I believe that was secondary adamantium.

On topic, I think that Juggernaut would be unscathed. Thanos would make it pretty easily as well -- I have no idea why there is a perception of him being weak to physical trauma in any case. SS has the best chance of the rest, as regardless of how hard adamantium is, Hulk still needs to be able to cleave SS into two, and SS has taken blows from Hulk before to little effect. I don't think he would make it, though.

Originally posted by Ouallada
I believe that was secondary adamantium.

Sure. Show me where Thor, under his own power, destroyed primary adamantium.

Juggernaut gets tickled to death.

Yo.

Originally posted by SoulDevourer
lol
if it wuz 2nd adamantium Thor wouldve pulverize it (like he did with Ultron copies who were made of 2nd adamantium)

I think this particular ref-point is about that statue of Hulk that Stark had made, which was *stated in-comic* to have been made out of Secondary A-metal; the most Thor managed to do was dent it somewat as I recall.

I think that was in Hulk #300.

Tazer

Originally posted by Ouallada
Sure. Show me where Thor, under his own power, destroyed primary adamantium.

Originally posted by SoulDevourer
if it wuz 2nd adamantium Thor wouldve pulverize

Originally posted by Tazer
Yo.

I think this particular ref-point is about that statue of Hulk that Stark had made, which was *stated in-comic* to have been made out of Secondary A-metal; the most Thor managed to do was dent it somewat as I recall.

I think that was in Hulk #300.

Tazer

i ment the bar of adamantium in the lab, Thor hits it & *slightly* dent it with his hammer

Originally posted by Ouallada
Hulk still needs to be able to cleave SS into two, and SS has taken blows from Hulk before to little effect. I don't think he would make it, though.

Juggernaut doesn't get cut in half. SS doesn't get cut in half. Thanos might not get cut in half.

The rest better pray they've got decent healing factors.

1.Lobo - gets sliced in half but heals backs within a few seconds and says quit fraggin around

2.inmortal Hercules - get sliced in half

3.WWH - sword goes half way in him but he doesn't dies

4.Classic Thor - dies

5.Ultimate Colossus(heterosexual for now) - dies

6.Thanos - gets knocked him down and gets cut (6 inches deep but he heals)

7.He-Man - not sure probably nothing(cut remember He-man ever being hurt by an object without it having to do with magic)

8.Captain Marvel(DC) - dies

9.Gladiator - with arms folded nothing happens; otherwise sword goes half way in him but he doesn't dies

10.SilverSurfer - dies

11.SuperMan - with hands on hips nothing happens; sword goes half way in him but he doesn't dies

12.Classic Juggernaut - falls down but nothing happens

Originally posted by SoulDevourer
the statue was stated *on panel* 2 be made of "pure adamantium" and "hardest substence known to man" but thats not what i ment

i ment the bar of adamantium in the lab, Thor hits it & *slightly* dent it with his hammer

The claim that Thor chipped said block was only verbal. None of the other characters saw any damage. Only Thor insisted he had damaged the adamantium block. If you have a scan that says otherwise, by all means.

Originally posted by nicamarvin
well thats because Hulk´s fists are made of flesh and SS skin is more durable than hulk´s fists, so no matter how strong hulk got, his fist will never pierce SS skin, but in this case he is weilding a very sharp Adamantium1 sword.... 😉

Which is why I said that SS' making it past this test is in doubt. There is evidence that Surfer can take Hulk's blows, though -- that much is certain. Surfer has also been cracked by physical blows (see Thanos), which means that it is still questionable if Hulk can cleave him in two.

Originally posted by Ouallada
The claim that Thor chipped said block was only verbal. None of the other characters saw any damage. Only Thor insisted he had damaged the adamantium block. If you have a scan that says otherwise, by all means.

if u got a scan saying adamantium is mystical then y all means

... A dent is a form of damage. Let's not get overly pedantic.

I do not think they wrote the comic superfluously. I do think that a verbal statement without panel proof is superfluous.

lol so u sayin they lied?
anyways if Hulk can damage it with fists then Thor doing some minor damage with HAMMER aint a stretch

None of the other Avengers saw any damage whatsoever. Only Thor insisted he had dented it. I don't need to say that anyone lied to show that is is debateable at best, or do we also accept all forms of verbal hyperbole as gospel truth now?

"slightly dent" is hyperbole? lol
good thing he didnt say he destroyed it huh

show a scan where it says adamantium is mystical

Originally posted by Ouallada
None of the other Avengers saw any damage whatsoever. Only Thor insisted he had dented it. I don't need to say that anyone lied to show that is is debateable at best, or do we also accept all forms of verbal hyperbole as gospel truth now?

or when Jug said his strenght easily equal Thors 😛

btw heres scan
http://img199.imageshack.us/img199/6024/tvas.jpg

theres pieces flying of the impact (only tiny pieces but thats consitent with thors statement)

It's not the "slightly" part that I am concerned about, it's the "dent" part. Until Thor has actually been shown on panel to have damaged primary adamantium, his claim is simply little more than idle boast, especially as no one else saw any damage whatsoever. That's along the same lines as making hyperbolic statements.

Show me a scan of a green Barney eating a corned beef sandwich. Has about as much relevance as you asking for a scan that has nothing to do with Thor not having dented adamantium.

Thor also dented Cap's sheild which is either equal of greater the adamantium