Sin City vs League of Extraordinary Gentlemen

Recent events of unexplainable supernatural activity have put citizens of Basin City, members of the Watchmen, and LXG against each other. Standard Equipment for all.

Team Sin City/Watchmen
*Detective Hartigan
*Marv
*Nite Owl (Special Guest courtesy of Watchmen)
*Kevin

Team LXG
*Alan Quartermain
*Mr. Hyde
*Captain Nemo
*Dorian Grey

Setting: Roark Family Ranch

Please description with your reasonings and explanations. Who wins?

I don't know...Mr. Hyde was like a Hulk in that movie...he could squash that other team solo, perhaps.

LXG, Dorian cannot be killed. Team SC should have Dwight.

Originally posted by Tattoos N Scars
I don't know...Mr. Hyde was like a Hulk in that movie...he could squash that other team solo, perhaps.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
LXG, Dorian cannot be killed. Team SC should have Dwight.

Dwight is overrated. Besides shoot at things in slow motion what skill/feats did he show?

Originally posted by Darth Martin
I'm not sure. I think he might have been vulnerable to gunfire. He was holding that shield up and it couldn't have provided much cover for Nemo's soldiers so I'm inclined to think he was giving himself some sort of cover. Marv on the other hand has lived from submachine gun fire from multiple individuals at the same time and been run over by cars multiple times in less than 30 seconds and got up with no extreme damage.

But Grey can be restrained as seen on film. He's got skill but can he hit Kevin? What if Kevin blinds him like he did Marv?

Dwight is overrated. Besides shoot at things in slow motion what skill/feats did he show?

True, but Mr. Hyde would be leagues beyond Marv in strength though. Marv would have to avoid being grabbed by Hyde..that dude could probably literally rip him in half.

Rip him in half? I don't think so. Marv is much tougher and has a much higher damage soak, not to mention a .45 caliber pistol.

Originally posted by Darth Martin

But Grey can be restrained as seen on film. He's got skill but can he hit Kevin? What if Kevin blinds him like he did Marv?

Dwight is overrated. Besides shoot at things in slow motion what skill/feats did he show?

Dwight is the best pistoleer in SC.

It does matter. If he's restrained to a wall like he was in LXG or tied up he's out of the fight. Wolverine can get out of most situations like that because of his adamantium claws. Grey has no such thing. How would he regenerate from being blinded? It's not a wound or puncture.

It's not just that. If I inserted Dwight I'd have to put someone in for LXG. Do you want Ms. Harker eating his ass?

Team Sin City/Watchmen
*Detective Hartigan: Can take the most abuse, possibly more than Marv. But I think Quartermain snuffs him with a head shot.

*Marv: Badass that he is, I dont think he stands a chance against Hyde.

*Nite Owl (Special Guest courtesy of Watchmen): No comment, I hate him.

*Kevin: SPEED......He'll tear Nemo a new *******.

Team LXG
*Alan Quartermain: Pretty much the best shot of any movie hero I have ever seen. He could possibly tae put Hartigan, Kevin and Nite Owl with three shots.

*Mr. Hyde: PWNS Marv.

*Captain Nemo: Fast, badas, but Kevin is faster and more badass.

*Dorian Grey: Cannot be killed.

Quartermain and Grey solo.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
It does matter. If he's restrained to a wall like he was in LXG or tied up he's out of the fight. Wolverine can get out of most situations like that because of his adamantium claws. Grey has no such thing. How would he regenerate from being blinded? It's not a wound or puncture.

It's not just that. If I inserted Dwight I'd have to put someone in for LXG. Do you want Ms. Harker eating his ass?

And yes, Grey heals from anything, he is immortal.

Originally posted by Rogue Jedi
How will team SC restrain him?

Hate Nite Owl or not, you can't excuse the fact that he's a beast. Don't see Grey doing anything to him. Kevin faster than Nemo? I'd say they're more like equals if only Kevin's slightly superior. Nemo hits harder and is more skilled. Not to mention he has weapons.

Originally posted by Darth Martin
It's his farm, I'm sure once he sees the guy's immortal they'd think of something.

Hate Nite Owl or not, you can't excuse the fact that he's a beast. Don't see Grey doing anything to him. Kevin faster than Nemo? I'd say they're more like equals if only Kevin's slightly superior. Nemo hits harder and is more skilled. Not to mention he has weapons.

Nite Owl's armor will protect him most likely. He's good with a firearm, yes, he'd shit his drawers if he had to take Dan H2H.

He wont have to go h2h, he will put a bullet in Nite Owl's face.

At night? It's like pitch black on that farm. Or maybe that's just our perspective because of the black and white.

Nite Owl sees clearer than anyone else here.

It never looked pitch black to me, Marv and Hartigan saw well enough.

In regards to Dorian Grey's "healing factor," it's not really a healing factor per se. All damage dealt to grey just kinda fades off into sand or whatever. He might feel it, as in the case when Mina caught him in the junk with the dagger, but there's no real wound opened. Kevin could "blind" Grey temporarily, but he'd be good as normal within seconds.

Unmportant, Quartermain pwns all but Marv.

And after he died, the shaman brought him back, there's no telling what powers they gave him when he was resurrected.

Originally posted by KingD19
And after he died, the shaman brought him back, there's no telling what powers they gave him when he was resurrected.

Let's go with Death Eye Beams and Super Strength.