Fleet battle pt 2

This is a fleet led by Thrawn, and a fleet led by Revan. Both have the same fleets, and the knowledge of how to use them. They have: 1 super star destoryer as the flagship, 5 star destroyers, 10 frigates, and a whole bunch of smaller things. The setting is above Malachor V, without the debris. The whole battle will be about who is the better commander, so who wins?

And plz dont say Thrawn just because Revan has no feats, it dosnt matter, this is his command skill, which was said to be one of the best ever.

EVER!!!! Plus he looks cool. Oh yeah, I WENT THERE!!!!!!!!!!!

❌

Galen marek wins.

Revan. His tactics rival and more than likely surpass Thrawns, plus he's incredibly powerful in the Force. Something Thrawn has no defense against.

KingD19
Revan.

maybeno

KingD19
His tactics rival and more than likely surpass Thrawns,

Given Thrawn's ridiculous accomplishments, I find that hard to believe. Prove it.

KingD19
plus he's incredibly powerful in the Force. Something Thrawn has no defense against.

Tell that to Outbound Flight. Oh, wait. You can't. 'Cause they're dead.

313

And fictional characters.

😐

Originally posted by KingD19
His tactics rival and more than likely surpass Thrawns,

thrawn absolutely slaughters him in any contest of intelligence.

Slaughters? IDK. Wins handily? Yeah.

slaughters |=| wins handily really.

Originally posted by Incanus
And plz dont say Thrawn just because Revan has no feats, it dosnt matter,

we're basically supposed to just pretend that revan is the greatest at everything without peer.

This is akin to pitting Hannibal against Alexander, no possible answer.

except in this case thrawn is hannibal and alexander's awesome military feats are heresay and unquantified.

in which case thrawn just wins. 😐

If this is purely hypothetical, it could actually be close. I said thrawn is a better tactician, but Revan's connection to the force is an advantage for him. Would be a fascinating battle though, that's for sure.

i cant remember. revan does not have battle meditation right?

if he does he can win.

He doesn't. Galen marek wins.

galen marek always wins.

no fair using skyfather level characters.

Originally posted by Ms.Marvel
except in this case thrawn is hannibal and alexander's awesome military feats are heresay and unquantified.

in which case thrawn just wins. 😐

Right, I forgot Revan was a mentally disabled retard that gibbers from the mouth and was simply credited for winning the Mandalorian Wars because the Republic has a soft spot for the mentally ill.

and... how exactly does that tie in with anything i said? 😐

i dont remember comparing him to a mentally retarded child...

Originally posted by Ms.Marvel
and... how exactly does that tie in with anything i said? 😐

i dont remember comparing him to a mentally retarded child...

Clearly you missed the sarcasm, but then that's not really surprising.