Would you rather have 3 more Star Wars movies or 50,000 dollars?

Would you rather have GL release 3 very high quality movies that that make the originals when they were released seem to be C rated movies in comparison, or get 50,000 dollars?

The latter, easily.

What a stupid question? Would I place my value of the original trilogy at or above $50,000? Hell, would I even put a monetary value on my enjoyment of them? Absolutely not. Again, stupid question.

Originally posted by Hewhoknowsall
Would you rather have GL release 3 very high quality movies that that make the originals when they were released seem to be C rated movies in comparison, or get 50,000 dollars?

I'd settle for $50.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
I'd settle for $50.

Like literally only 50 (without the 3 extra zeros) dollars?

If so, then you really must not be a big Star Wars fan.

Major premise: That any Star Wars fan would prefer to expand the Saga.
Minor premise: That Lucien does not want to expand the saga.
Conclusion: Lucien is not a Star Wars fan.

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
Major premise: That any Star Wars fan would prefer to expand the Saga.
Minor premise: That Lucien does not want to expand the saga.
Conclusion: Lucien is not a Star Wars fan.

Don't rub it in. We don't need to be reminded of his stupidity and it's unprofessional.

hmmm... I would take 100 dollars. i'd forgo 50 for 3 more movies, but i'd take 100.

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
Major premise: That any Star Wars fan would prefer to expand the Saga.
Minor premise: That Lucien does not want to expand the saga.
Conclusion: Lucien is not a Star Wars fan.

hey... i would take 10 bucks not to see another star wars movie. pt was enough for me, especially since i don't like any movies the public would consider "grade A' or art. most of the films i like are grungy action or just plain entertaining. Example: i enjoy watching t2 more than forest gump (I like forrest gump, but w/e).

Originally posted by Red Nemesis
Major premise: That any Star Wars fan would prefer to expand the Saga.
Minor premise: That Lucien does not want to expand the saga.
Conclusion: Lucien is not a Star Wars fan.

All Star Wars fans are people that want to expand the Star Wars saga.
No persons identical to Lucien are people that want to expand the Star Wars Saga.
-----------------------------------------------
No persons identical to Lucien are Star Wars fans.

AEE - 2

Unconditionally Valid both Boolean and Aristotelian.

are we going on a star wars fan witch-hunt now? if so i'm about to get burned.

This is why arguing from axioms fails so often.

(Didn't we have the same thing?

any Star Wars fan would prefer to expand the Saga = All Star Wars fans are people that want to expand the Star Wars saga

Lucien does not want to expand the saga = No persons identical to Lucien are people that want to expand the Star Wars Saga

Lucien is not a Star Wars fan = No persons identical to Lucien are Star Wars fans

The only difference is that "Lucien" is expanded to be a category of people that are identical to Lucien?)

I took what you said and changed it into a standard form categorical syllogism. That's about it.

It should be noted that valid deductive argument is not necessarily sound. Valid and sound are two different things.

It should be noted that neither one of you would score well on a logical reasoning portion of the LSAT.

It should also be noted that I'm influential and important enough to merit my having my own category of mentality.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
It should also be noted that I'm influential and important enough to merit my having my own category of mentality.

Spoiler:
retarded

Originally posted by mattatom
You are quite correct Lucien, yours is below

Spoiler:
retarded

.

Originally posted by Lord Lucien
In that case allow me to officially recognize you as the leading member.