Star Wars universe vs Lord of the Rings universe (explained)

1. An ARMY vs. ARMY battle, with the GROUND military forces of the Grand Army of the Republic, the Galactus Empire and the GFFA going up against all of LOTR armies. Anybody Sauron and below is allowed for the LOTR side.

2. A GROUP battle: EU Luke, Yoda and Mace Windu vs the Fellowship, Force only allowed to enhance senses and pre cog.

3. An ALL OUT ARMY battle, like 1, only EVERYBODY except for Valar/Eru are allowed.

Anyone?

1. SW; Much better technology.
2. Jedi/Sith are much better swordsman than LOTR characters.
3. You've lost me.

You can't compare the LOTR and SW universes. Too much of a difference in tech.

1. Star Wars
2. Star Wars
3. You've lost me

i think this war is won on the knees.

Nobody argues for LOTR?

Well, I agree that Star Wars stomps in all 3 (although 2 might be difficult)

By 3. I mean land, space, etc. all allowed...

EU Luke would kill every Maiar at once.

Originally posted by NemeBro
EU Luke would kill every Maiar at once.

Na, Luke has a penis (I'm pretty sure), Witch King of Angmar is protected from cock-wielders, it's protective prophecy, ya know.

EU Luke is illegal here.

Movie feats only.

Star Wars x 3

Never seen any of those movies.

Originally posted by Impediment
EU Luke is illegal here.

Movie feats only.

In a normal vs. match I would agree, but if the OP specifies he is allowed why should he not be?

The EU is nothing more than an expansion of the universe shown in the movies, with EU Luke being an expansion of movie Luke.

Originally posted by Quincy
Never seen any of those movies.

Star Wars:

Has the Force (although this is actually one of the least important of their advantages)
Has ships that can travel at billions of times the speed of light
Has star destroyers with energy output in the millions of Hiroshima atmoic bombs per shot
Has an entire galaxy of troops and resources
etc.

Lord of the Rings

Has swords and shields of pretty high quality
Some of the dudes use magic
Has Sauron
Has Dragons and stuff
etc.

Originally posted by Quincy
Never seen any of those movies.

Question:

Does EU Luke have an EU penis?

Question:

If the EU nonsense is allowed, does that mean that all works of LoTR is allowed as well?

Statement:

Magic > The Force 24/7.

Originally posted by NemeBro
Why?

In a normal vs. match I would agree, but if the OP specifies he is allowed why should he not be?

The EU is nothing more than an expansion of the universe shown in the movies, with EU Luke being an expansion of movie Luke.

Because EU Luke was never seen on screen. The rule is "on screen feat ONLY".

The thread started has failed to adhere to my recommendations to change the scenario, so thread closed.