Alan Rickman is a horrible Snape.

Originally posted by BlackZero30x
that's funny because from what I hear J.K based Snape off of Alan Rickman......

i'd like to see proof of this..

but either way, it doesnt matter. my main point as that he doesn't play the part the way it's written...

when she was writing crazy, emotional scenes with snape, picturing rickman.. i doubt she imagined him droning on and on

well that's what i hear...not something i know for sure.

I think he's great as snape. His true test will be Deathly Hallows.

I did get use to him and that is true in the last book you will see his true colors.

Originally posted by allofyousuckkk
i'd like to see proof of this..

but either way, it doesnt matter. my main point as that he doesn't play the part the way it's written...

when she was writing crazy, emotional scenes with snape, picturing rickman.. i doubt she imagined him droning on and on

That's called bad directing, not acting. Alan Rickman can play a very emotional person just fine.

It's the fact the HP movies are abominations in every sense of the word. If the director told Rickman to act like how Snape acts like in teh book, he would.

But guess what? He plays the part is paid to play. He reads the lines he is paid to read.

That's it.

So blame the horrible movie, not one of the few good things about it.

I argee^