I'd take team 2 in this one.
Infinity man has always been stronger than supes level & has a vast amount of powers that he actually uses effectively.
Orion has an AoA blast thats hugely powerful and he likes opening up with.
Magog was giving a good showing against a team with KC supes, Alan scott & a couple of other bordering top tiers*.
Id give those 3 decent chances against any of the other teams.
* Starman, Obsidian, Powergirl & steel are debatably true top tiers. Im not siding either way, id just hesistate to outright say yay or nay cause its a pointless argument. Point is that magog is powerful.