Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Lol. I wonder why it was bumped.
Well Celey and Abhi got into an argument, I think in the OWAW Thor topic. The whole Superman/Kal-L fight from INFINITE CRISIS got brought-up, and the two argued over it. Celey posted a link to this thread where a bunch of posters started attacking Abhi.
A big reason about the argument was Rage posting a quote that was allegedly by the author. Supposedly a poster on HeroChat emailed the author and posted what he said there. I never saw this thread, let alone know anything to indicate it was legit from the writer. But a lot of people focused on that as proving Abhi wrong. Another part was that "there was so little collateral damage on Earth-2 in INFINITE CRISIS."
Ironic because many in the thread Celey was most recently arguing with Abhi in, Abhi posted a quote and link from someone asking questions to Geoff Johns, and link, that when asked why the space/time destruction and planet destroying stuff didn't show-up in INFINITE CRISIS but the Superman title tie-ins, he said there wasn't enough room in the comic, and that it'd be best to let the tie-ins look at the "fall out" of their punches, but people dismissed.
I also find it ironic that Celey is bringing up this thread about a bunch of people ganging-up on Abhi "for being wrong," yet in the same thread prior to the Abhi attack, Celey had gotten the Soulfire Darkseid busting example completely wrong, starting around page 22. Well, at least where he first disagrees with Abhi.
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=520290&pagenumber=22
Page 23 is where he really gets things wrong, claiming Darkseid "cut him from his power source," when the New Gods soul cache wasn't THAT kind of "power source." But nobody really ganged-up on him. More and more, I'm seeing posters here attack Abhi more for being Abhi than his actual arguments.