She's beaten like, 3 jedi masters at once and stalemated Obi and Ani (who looked pretty good against Dooku in da CW movie) and council members. She's hardcore dude. edit: Hey, she beaten Sora Bulq too! I didn't know that. edit: Damn, he was probably faking losing.
Lumiya got her ass kicked by Nelani and random jedi master Tresina Lobi, even though she had Alema to help her.
🙄
Tresina Lobi fended off both Lumiya and Alema Rar (and scored blows against both) simultaneously in a protracted engagement.
Looking at it from a realistic perspective, Lumiya is rather like Mara Jade -- an unbelievably skilled assassin, saboteur, and political operative possessing a wide array of requisite skills and talents. She's clearly a skilled strategist and tactician, and is sufficiently skilled with a lightsaber to hold her own against powerful swordsmen.
But she isn't top tier as a straight-forward duelist; she's not even close.
1. Lumiya is far more trained than Luke and possesses a ruthless disposition; she defeats him pretty handily.
2. Not sure; I'm pretty ignorant for Jacen's feats circa NJO.
3. Shaak Ti is one of the Jedi Council's most prolific swordsmen and, according to the novelization, more than held her own against Starkiller.
In a straightforward fight, Ti overcomes Lumiya with moderate difficulty. If Lumiya is resourceful and judicious, she could squeeze a victory here.
4. Sora Bulq was one of the greatest swordsmen in galactic history. In a straightforward fight, he annihilates her. But he doesn't seem too bright, so again, it depends on the circumstances.
5. Qui-Gon was another vaunted duelist whose skills seem to be in excess of Lumiya's own; he's also very clever, so I don't see her winning here.
6. Lumiya seems cleverer than Ventress, but I'd put them at about the same skill level as far as dueling is concerned. Lumiya would likely win this one, but it could be very close.
7. Dooku wastes her effortlessly.
8. See 7.
9. Caedus would find a way to **** up and Lumiya would win.
10. We already saw this one.