Generally a tie. Circumstances may side one team over the other. The balance of physical power is essentially equal, as Diana is classically as strong as Hercules, and Superman and Thor are in the same class in direct strength vs. strength (though Supes can apply his strength in ways Thor can't readily, but that doesn't apply here).
Originally posted by iceman24567
Diana = Herc not so much all are stronger than Diana
? Diana has demonstrated consistantly, in multiple comic "re-interpretations" over the decades, as being "as strong as Hercules", and certainly over the past decade or so as being nearly as strong as Superman, to the extent that they can be functionally considered equals in terms of raw strength/power under normal circumstances (as Supes himself acknowledged in "The Circle" and in stories after that). While not wanting to get down to the nitty-gritty of who can exactly lift "x" weight, Diana=Hercules, in general strength, and Supes and Thor are more or less equal (any "god-power" advantage Thor may have, contextually, not readily applying in a scenario like this one). Like I said, a tie, assuming no "cheating" occurs (flight, power-counter attacks, et al).
Originally posted by Sasaraixx
Hardly.Even in the worst case scenario, Diana = Herc, Superman is still a little stronger than Thor. Team 1 still wins.
Not really. I'm assuming this is Hercules at the level that his equal to Thor. Meaning I'd rank them as....
Superman = Thor =/> Hercules > Diana
But that depends on how you view their fights. Does Thor get dragged down to Hercules' level or does Hercules get dragged up to Thor's level?
I view Diana as being stronger than Hercules. In her exact power description by D.C. she is blessed with strength greater than that of Hercules.
Now some may say the the greek Hercules is not the same as the Hercules of Marvel or the Hercules that CM is based off of. Well I can't speak for the former the certainly CM is indeed based off the greek Hercules. Otherwise, why would D.C. show the actual greek Hercules when CM obtains his power, and why would D.C. use the name Hercules for CM's strength power instead another name (like the one BA uses)?
As for the former (Marvel Hercules) we can only use feats to determine who is stronger. So based off one of Diana's greatest feats, I calculated her to exert the force of the weight of the Earth.